Monday, June 20, 2005

Flash - Kansas Teachers Are Required to Take a Vow of Poverty

1 Corinthians 1:26-29 (New Living Translation)

26 “Remember, dear brothers and sisters, that few of you were wise in the world's eyes, or powerful, or wealthy when God called you. 27Instead, God deliberately chose things the world considers foolish in order to shame those who think they are wise. And he chose those who are powerless to shame those who are powerful. 28God chose things despised by the world, things counted as nothing at all, and used them to bring to nothing what the world considers important, 29so that no one can ever boast in the presence of God.”

The Kansas Legislature has been called into special session to attempt to find a hundred and forty three million dollars to fix the state’s education “problems.” Some Kansas lawmakers are threatening to defy the state Supreme Court order that set this frantic search in motion. The Kansas City Star’s editorial page today described the defiance this way:

“Kansas watchers now wait breathlessly to see if the Legislature will set another off-the-wall precedent by defying the state Supreme Court’s order to put more money in the schools.”

“They might fine and imprison legislators, but I’m willing to ‘do the time’ to protect our constitutional separation of powers,” Rep.Jim Morrison, a
Colby Republican, wrote in a letter published by the Hays Daily News.”

While I’m not a big fan of the Supreme Court’s plan, I think that defying a court order under these circumstances would be foolhardy. It’s one thing to throw money at education problems. That’s counter-productive enough. But refusing the court’s order would send a terrible message. It would in a sense be telling all of us that we don’t have to obey laws or follow rules that we don’t like. While there are times when I could see this kind of civil disobedience as viable, this is not one of those times.

While I fail to see the principle of the legislators who are threatening to defy the court, I also fail to see that a hundred and forty three million dollars is going to solve the education problem in Kansas.

This is all making great editorial fodder for Patrick Kelley at the Gazette. In this weekend’s edition he penned an editorial titled “Representative Honors” in which he made a not too subtle plea for increases in teachers’ salaries. The piece really should have spent more time honoring the five inductees to the National Teachers Hall of Fame than he did on giving the City of Emporia his bi-weekly shakedown.

This is what he had to say about the honorees:

“So tonight, as the five 2005 inductees are honored by the National Teachers Hall of Fame, take it as a given that each of them is there as a representative of thousands of other teachers who, every year, give their best to the children of America.”

Now how could anyone argue with that? I’m grateful for good teachers and so are the good people of Emporia. I even think that our legislators appreciate the work teachers do in the classroom.

But that wasn’t what Patrick Kelley was writing about. I’ve learned in my six years it’s never that simple with him. He had money on his mind, pure and simple:

“Teaching has never been an easy job, if it’s done right, and it becomes more difficult every year.”

“For all the trust we place in teachers and all the power we give them over the next generation, we don’t pay them very well at all.”

“Think teachers’ pay is fair? How much does a good teacher earn in the Emporia public schools? How much does a good plumber earn in this city?”

“That’s not a slam at plumbers, who are worth every penny they are paid. But good teachers are worth much more than they are paid.”

“It’s a wonder that so many students choose to spend four or five years in college – an expensive choice – so they can take a vow of poverty and become teachers after graduation.”


Well, upon reading the first few lines of his plea, I found my sympathies aligned with his. He almost had me. But then he couldn’t resist being the snake oil salesman. I got to the words “so they can take a vow of poverty” and my jaws clenched shut. I was absolutely mortified. I did not realize that we were literally starving our teachers to death. After a few minutes of reflection, though, I came to my senses. In that spirit of sanity I fired a letter back to Mssr. Kelley and his gang down at the Gazette:

“I was actually feeling quite sympathetic until I checked some statistical data. According to nationmaster.com the United States ranks fifth world-wide in terms of teachers’ salaries. While it’s not on par with professional baseball players, it’s a bit more than most of the good folks of Emporia who work at Wal-Mart, Montana Mike’s or Tyson Foods.”

“By the way Mr. Kelley, I wasn’t aware that teachers had to take a vow of poverty. How did that get by the watchful eye of the NEA? I must have missed something in my education because I thought vows like that were reserved for folks like Mother Theresa who worked with the poor and dying in Calcutta.”

By now most teachers who have read this far think that I’m an insensitive brute. I’m not. I think that teachers should be well compensated for what they do. I also think that policemen and women should. And, like Mr. Kelley, I think that plumbers are worth their weight in lucre. I also have the same feelings about electricians, carpenters, cabinet makers, doctors, lawyers, sales clerks, waiters, waitresses, and the pastor of my church. Just ask those I’ve interacted with and they’ll confirm that I’m a pretty generous soul. But when someone like Patrick Kelley abused hyperbole like he did this past Saturday my suspicions went into high gear. “What was his real point?” I now ask myself. With the benefit of two days worth of hindsight it’s all coming into focus. In ascribing to teachers the virtues of a saint he’s attempting to not only get them more money, but more power in our children’s lives.

It all comes down to a couple of things for me. No teacher I know is a Mother Theresa. Not one! Not even the best of them.

A bit of Mother Theresa’s biography follows. It’s done so that you, the reader, can draw some comparisons. In doing so I’m not trying to denigrate the teaching profession. It’s being done to compare the good work that teachers do with the high, noble calling of this great woman:

“Born Agnes Gonxha Bojaxhiu on August 26, 1910, in Skopje, Macedonia, in the former Yugoslavia, she was the youngest of three children. In her teens, Agnes became a member of a youth group in her local parish called Sodality. Through her involvement with their activities guided by a Jesuit priest, Agnes became interested in missionaries. At age 17, she responded to her first call of a vocation as a Catholic missionary nun. She joined an Irish order, the Sisters of Loretto, a community known for their missionary work in India. When she took her vows as a Sister of Loretto, she chose the name Teresa after Saint Thérèse of Lisieux.”

“In Calcutta, Sister Teresa taught geography and cathechism at St. Mary's High School. In 1944, she became the principal of St. Mary's. Soon Sister Teresa contracted tuberculosis, was unable to continue teaching and was sent to Darjeeling for rest and recuperation. It was on the train to Darjeeling that she received her second call – “the call within the call” Mother Teresa recalled later, “I was to leave the convent and work with the poor, living among them. It was an order. I knew where I belonged but I did not know how to get there.”

“In 1948, the Vatican granted Sister Teresa permission to leave the Sisters of Loretto and pursue her calling under the jurisdiction of the Archbishop of Calcutta.”

“Mother Teresa started with a school in the slums to teach the children of the poor. She also learned basic medicine and went into the homes of the sick to treat them. In 1949, some of her former pupils joined her. They found men, women, and children dying on the streets who were rejected by local hospitals. The group rented a room so they could care for helpless people otherwise condemned to die in the gutter. In 1950, the group was established by the Church as a Diocesan Congregation of the Calcutta Diocese. It was known as the Missionaries of Charity.”


There are many good teachers, but there are very, very few Mother Theresa’s who pass our way.

There’s also something else Patrick Kelley missed when he alluded to vows of poverty. People like Mother Theresa, who actually live these vows, wouldn’t be allowed to teach in our public schools today. If she came through the doors of an American public school right now and said what she said in 1994 she’d be shown the door as quickly as you could say “Teach your children well:”

“But I feel that the greatest destroyer of peace today is abortion, because it is a war against the child, a direct killing of the innocent child, murder by the mother herself.”

“And if we accept that a mother can kill even her own child, how can we tell other people not to kill one another? How do we persuade a woman not to have an abortion? As always, we must persuade her with love and we remind ourselves that love means to be willing to give until it hurts. Jesus gave even His life to love us. So, the mother who is thinking of abortion, should be helped to love, that is, to give until it hurts her plans, or her free time, to respect the life of her child. The father of that child, whoever he is, must also give until it hurts.”

“By abortion, the mother does not learn to love, but kills even her own child to solve her problems.”

“And, by abortion, the father is told that he does not have to take any responsibility at all for the child he has brought into the world. That father is likely to put other women into the same trouble. So abortion just leads to more abortion.”

“Any country that accepts abortion is not teaching its people to love, but to use any violence to get what they want. This is why the greatest destroyer of love and peace is abortion.”

“Many people are very, very concerned with the children of India, with the children of Africa where quite a few die of hunger, and so on. Many people are also concerned about all the violence in this great country of the United States. These concerns are very good. But often these same people are not concerned with the millions who are being killed by the deliberate decision of their own mothers. And this is what is the greatest destroyer of peace today - abortion which brings people to such blindness.”

I think we all know what would happen if she said something like that in a public school. The ACLU would have a battery of lawyers filing lawsuits aimed at protecting our children from religious fanatics like her and her ilk and the NEA would be rhetorically ripping this noble saint to shreds.

In the end I think I really do believe that I’ve figured out why Patrick Kelley wanted more money for teachers. It is, as I said earlier, simply to give them more money and then we’ll have to give them more power over our kids. His words reveal what the heart of the matter is to him - “For all the trust we place in teachers and all the power we give them over the next generation, we don’t pay them very well at all.” That’s it! More money! More power! And that’s the real crux of the problem here in Kansas.

I think of what’s happening to Kansas school kids today and ask myself, “Where are the Mother Theresas today when you need them?” “At the ACLU?” “At the NEA?” “At the Gazette?” I think, regrettably, we know the answers to those questions.

Sunday, June 19, 2005

The Great Need of Our Generation - "Men With Chests"

Joshua 1:6-7 (New Living Translation)

6 “Be strong and courageous, for you will lead my people to possess all the land I swore to give their ancestors. 7Be strong and very courageous. Obey all the laws Moses gave you. Do not turn away from them, and you will be successful in everything you do.”

This seems an appropriate time to sandwich some thoughts between what I’ve written about for the past couple of days and what I’m going tow rite about tomorrow. To do this I’m going to use a couple of passages from C.S. Lewis’s “The Abolition of Man.”

Like most of Lewis’s work this one was short and sweet. There are few thinkers I’ve read and wrestled with who can pack more into a small space than “Jack.” The book, written in 1943, actually started as a series of lectures. His purpose in putting the lectures into writing was to give wider dissemination to his thoughts on universals, courage, honor, self-sacrifice, and so forth that had been passed down from generation to generation. It was also his response to the educational stream and philosophy of the day that concluded that the emotionalism that values like courage, patriotism, and self-sacrifice brought to bear in men needed to be replaced by a cool rationalism. In today’s terms this rationalism would mean that there really isn’t anything worth giving one’s life for, and that thinking rationally would preclude these outdated and useless notions. This stream, Lewis argued, stripped men of their souls and left them as “men without chests.”

Things, unfortunately, have only gotten worse over time. For sixty years now our educational systems have stripped soul after soul of its virtue. What Lewis saw prophetically is now a twenty first century reality. Knowing that, I believe that his work is sorely needed now, some three generations after he penned them.

His thoughts, with mine interspersed to add continuity, follow.

First and foremost, Lewis declared that these values could, and should be taught. They were, in this great man’s mind, the glue that held civilization together:

“I think that Gaius and Titius may have honestly misunderstood the pressing educational need of the moment. They see the world around them swayed by emotional propaganda – they have learned from tradition that youth is sentimental – and they conclude that the best thing they can do is to fortify the minds of young people against emotion. My own experience as a teacher tells an opposite tale. For every one pupil who needs to be guarded from a weak excess of sensibility there are three who need to be awakened from the slumber of cold vulgarity. The task of the modern educator is not to cut down jungles but to irrigate deserts. The right defence against false sentiments is to inculcate just sentiments. By starving the sensibility of our pupils we only make them easier prey to the propagandist when he comes. For famished nature will be avenged and a hard heart is no infallible protection against a soft head.”

Then, in one grand section, Lewis attacks the modern idea of “intellectualism:”

“the operation of The Green Book and its kind is to produce what may be called Men without Chests. It is an outrage that they should be commonly spoken of as Intellectuals. This gives them the chance to say that he who attacks them attacks Intelligence. It is not so. They are not distinguished from other men by any unusual skill in finding truth nor any virginal ardour to pursue her. Indeed it would be strange if they were: a persevering devotion truth, a nice sense of intellectual honor, cannot be long maintained without the aid of a sentiment which Gaius and Titius could debunk as easily as any other. It is not excess of thought but defect of fertile and generous emotion that marks them out. Their heads are no bigger than the ordinary: it is the atrophy of the chest beneath that makes them so.”

Lewis closes this lecture with a wry lament, asking, in a sense, why we’re so shocked that the very things we need (courage, honor, self-sacrifice, etc.) are in such short supply:

“And all the time – such is the tragic-comedy of our situation – we continue to clamour for those very qualities we are rendering impossible. You can hardly open a periodical without coming across the statement that what our civilization needs is more ‘drive,’ or dynamism, or self-sacrifice, or ‘creativity.’ In a sort of ghastly simplicity we remove the organ and demand the function. We make men without chests and expect of them virtue and enterprise. We laugh at honour and are shocked to find traitors in our midst. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful.”

The lament of Lewis’s 1940’s is now the sad reality of 2005. The tragedy of education without virtue has indeed produced “men without chests.” Of all the great tasks facing civilization now the need to rebuild is the most pressing. We’re now three generations behind in making honorable citizens and time is getting away from us. We must do something!

Saturday, June 18, 2005

Thinking Clearly, Thinking Rationally

“Ignorance of history destroys our judgment. Consider Sen. Dick Durbin (D-Ill), who just compared the Guantanamo Bay detention center to Stalin's gulag and to the death camps of Hitler and Pol Pot — an astonishing, obscene piece of ignorance. Between 15 million and 30 million people died from 1918 through 1956 in the prisons and labor camps of the Soviet gulag. Historian Robert Conquest gives some facts. A prisoner at the Kholodnaya Gora prison had to stuff his ears with bread before sleeping on account of the shrieks of women being interrogated. At the Kolyma in Siberia, inmates labored through 12-hour days in cheap canvas shoes, on almost no food, in temperatures that could go to minus-58. At one camp, 1,300 of 3,000 inmates died in one year.” “Gulag” must not go the way of “Nazi” and become virtually meaningless. Europeans love calling Israelis “Nazis” — a transparent attempt to slough off their guilt like rattlesnakes shedding skin. (“See, the Jews are as bad as we were!”) I'd like to ban the word “Nazi” except when applied to … Nazis. Lawbreakers would be ordered to learn what Nazi actually means.”

-
David Gelernter

If statistics mean anything, I’m batting five hundred right now. On my post about Dick Durbin and Fred Phelps a couple of days ago there were two comments supporting my views and two dissenting. Not bad at all in a free marketplace of ideas.

I rarely do this, but I thought I’d take a few moments to respond to those who disagreed with what I had to say.

Before I launch out, let me say that I appreciate comments, either pro or con. I recognize that the stuff I write doesn’t generate a lot of “heat,” but when it does I don’t expect everyone to agree with me, nor do I expect those who disagree with me to put on kid gloves when they comment. The only guideline I have is civility. In the case of the two that disagreed with the picture I painted of Senator Dick Durbin the tone of the response was indeed civil. So, if they have the chance to read today’s post I want to thank them for that, but to also say that I disagree with their assessment for a few reasons.

In both cases the “con” commenters chided me on my lack of intellectual honesty. I re-read my post and, knowing myself, didn’t see it as an intellectual exercise. It was an emotional response, and I think a fair reading of what I said would see it for what it was.

Now, that’s not to say that an emotional response is a bad thing. One of the things that really bothers me is hearing, at the most inappropriate times, “Don’t respond emotionally. Let’s let cooler heads, impeccable logic, and reason prevail.” Now I can be as cool headed and dispassionate as anyone I know, but there are times when my emotions do get engaged. Such was the case when Dick Durbin called American soldiers Nazis and Fred Phelps picketed the funeral of an American soldier killed in the line of duty in Iraq. After reading what the senator said and about what the “reverend” was doing I didn’t immediately say to myself, “Phil, think clearly. Disabuse yourself of your emotions and make this an intellectual exercise.” I simply responded from the gut and I stand by what I said.

There’s an implication in the responses of my critics. In order to have been right, my response should have been intellectual, because “intellectual” thinking is “honest” thinking. Now I’ll grant that intellectual thinking can be a good thing. Most often it is. But I will not grant that in making an emotional response to these two men is a bad thing. In fact, I believe in the whole man concept, that the emotions and the intellect can fit smartly together. To that end I’ll now try to put the two together and respond a bit more dispassionately than I did the other day.

First, this isn’t an intellectual exercise in the purest sense. That type of thinking I leave to good men like David Gelernter, who I quoted in my introduction.

Here, then, is my “clear-headed” take on these recent events.

First, I do not believe that what “purportedly” occurred at Guantanamo comes even close to the work of Hitler or Stalin or Pol Pot. It doesn’t even come remotely close!

I’ll make a comparison now for my critics. The U.S. military has a code of conduct, called the U.S. Fighting Man’s Code of Conduct. Much of the code deals with expectations for those who are captured. The last article of the code, article six, is a blanket statement that covers expected conduct at all times:

VI “I will never forget that I am an American fighting man, responsible for my actions, and dedicated to the principles which made my country free. I will trust in my God and in the United States of America. (my emphasis added)”

Compare that with the code of sorts that Stalin and his underlings operated under:

“The “sword-bearers” had to believe with Messianic faith, in order to act with the correct ruthlessness, and to convince others they were right to do so. Stalin’s “quasi-Islamic” fanaticism was typical of the Bolshevik magnates: Mikoyan’s son called his father “a Bolshevik fanatic.” Most came from devoutly religious backgrounds. They hated Judeo-Christianity – but the orthodoxy of their parents was replaced by something even more rigid, a systematic amorality: “This religion – or science, as it was modestly called by its adepts – invests man with godlike authority.”

The fruit of the two philosophies can be clearly seen in the numbers. At the risk of being accused of faulty exegesis I’ll paraphrase from Holy Writ – “American soldiers have made a hundred or so terrorists crap their pants while “Uncle Joe” has slain his millions.”

There is, I submit, no comparison to be made, and to say otherwise is ludicrous. I agree with Professor Gelernter that a history lesson is in order for Senator Durbin.

Now if the good senator and his supporters want to make some comparisons I suggest they make some between the terrorists who killed three thousand Americans on September 11, 2001. I suggest they draw some comparisons between Saddam Hussein and Stalin or Hitler. I think if they did Saddam would be quite flattered. He was a big fan of these two pariahs, if my memory of history serves me well.

To compare what’s going on at Guantanamo with this sordid history is, intellectually speaking, offensive!

Here’s another comparison the critics ought to make. What are the “detainees” at Guantanamo eating these days? This is the way the menu was described by California Congressman Duncan Hunter:

“For nearly every question that reporters asked about aggressive interrogations and lack of judicial process involving the 500-plus detainees, Hunter's answers were “honey-glazed chicken” or “lemon-baked fish,” served with whole wheat pita, various vegetables and fruit.”

“The inmates in Guantanamo have never eaten better, they've never been treated better and they've never been more comfortable in their lives. ... And the idea that somehow we are torturing people in Guantanamo is absolutely not true, unless you consider having to eat chicken three times a week is torture,” Hunter said at the news conference.”

“Hunter passed out copies of the daily menus for the detainees and displayed two typical meals. He said the detainees are “fed better than thousands and thousands of our troops in the field.”


I wonder, by way of comparison, what the food was like at Dachau or in the Soviet gulags? I wonder, by way of comparison, if the innocents paraded through these evil systems could ever complain about too much “honey-glazed chicken?”

The questions are only rhetorical, of course. Anyone intellectually honest knows the answers to them.

I’ll speak now from personal experience, a trip Nancy and I took to Germany, Austria, and the Czech Republic. One of the day trips during that time was to the concentration camp at Dachau. It was a chilling, and necessary experience. What was especially chilling to me was the incredible efficiency of the “operation.” There, just outside a small city known for its affinity for the arts, Jews, gays, evangelicals, and other assorted enemies of the state were dealt with brutally. It was there that prisoners of war were immersed in freezing water in experiments to determine what the limits of the human body were. It was there children were used in grisly medical experiments. It was there that thousands and thousands were fed nothing more than bread and water. When the war ended and the camp was liberated the few emaciated living remaining were vivid testaments to the menu at Dachau.

Once again, as Professor Gelernter said, the critics need a history lesson.

For what it’s worth, now, I’m going to try a hypothetical. I’m going to ask my critics what they would have done on September 10, 2001 if they had a terrorist in their custody, a terrorist who knew the intimate details of the plot to crash airliners into buildings like those at the World Trade Center. What would they do? Would they chain them to a wall? Would they let them crap their pants and make them sit in it? What would they do if they knew a son or a daughter was going to be visiting one of the targets on September 11th? What would they do if they knew one of my sons or my daughter or my grandchildren were going to be on top of the Twin Towers that fateful day? Would they tweak the terrorist’s nose a bit to get the information needed? Would they kick him in the groin? Or, would they act in a “civilized” manner and then, after the evil deed was done, excoriate the political administration and the military for not doing enough to protect us?”

Those questions are also only rhetorical, but I think I know what the answers would be.

Honestly, I think there is in the minds of men like Dick Durbin a real thread of deceit. I don’t believe that he really cares what’s going on in Guantanamo or to Americans now serving in harm’s way. This is nothing more to men like him than political capital. That, I believe, is the truth of the matter.

I recognize that there are limits to what can, or should be done. Having served for eight years in the military I also know that military leadership and their civilian counterparts at the Department of Defense know there are limits as well. Knowing that, I remain convinced that Guantanamo is no Dachau, nor is it a gulag or a Cambodian re-education camp. In all honesty I do not believe that being forced to sit in a room with the air conditioner turned up or being forced to listen to rap music while chained to the floor comes close to comparing the historical events I’ve mentioned. In fact, I believe it comes close to being offensive to people of good will, the brave Americans who fought to liberate Europe and Asia, and to the people who survived those grisly days.

Well, I think I’ve had enough dispassionate thinking for one day. It’s time for me to get back to just being my emotional self. To that end, I say now as I said a few days ago, Dick Durbin and Fred Phelps are lunacy’s “A” team.

Thursday, June 16, 2005

Dick Durbin and Fred Phelps - Lunacy's "A" Team

Matthew 7:21-24 (New Living Translation)

True Disciples

21 “Not all people who sound religious are really godly. They may refer to me as “Lord,”but they still won't enter the Kingdom of Heaven. The decisive issue is whether they obey my Father in heaven. 22On judgment day many will tell me, “Lord, Lord, we prophesied in your name and cast out demons in your name and performed many miracles in your name.” 23But I will reply, “I never knew you. Go away; the things you did were unauthorized.”

I thought it might have been one of those “full moon” things, but then I checked a universal calendar and found out that wasn’t the case. Maybe there was just something in the air. Whatever it was it afflicted Senator Dick Durbin of Illinois and the “reverend” Fred Phelps in a mighty way. If I were to diagnose the malady I would have to say that it was either foot in mouth disease of head up rectum syndrome.

The good senator took the lead in this mess when he did a bit of pontificating in the well of the senate, believing, I surmise, that what he said would never make it into the public arena. That assumption was every bit as foolish as his remarks:

“When you read some of the graphic descriptions of what has occurred here [at Guantanamo Bay]--I almost hesitate to put them in the [Congressional] Record, and yet they have to be added to this debate. Let me read to you what one FBI agent saw. And I quote from his report”:

“On a couple of occasions, I entered interview rooms to find a detainee chained hand and foot in a fetal position to the floor, with no chair, food or water. Most times they urinated or defecated on themselves, and had been left there for 18-24 hours or more. On one occasion, the air conditioning had been turned down so far and the temperature was so cold in the room, that the barefooted detainee was shaking with cold. . . . On another occasion, the [air conditioner] had been turned off, making the temperature in the unventilated room well over 100 degrees. The detainee was almost unconscious on the floor, with a pile of hair next to him. He had apparently been literally pulling his hair out throughout the night. On another occasion, not only was the temperature unbearably hot, but extremely loud rap music was being played in the room, and had been since the day before, with the detainee chained hand and foot in the fetal position on the tile floor.”


“If I read this to you and did not tell you that it was an FBI agent describing what Americans had done to prisoners in their control, you would most certainly believe this must have been done by Nazis, Soviets in their gulags, or some mad regime--Pol Pot or others--that had no concern for human beings. Sadly, that is not the case. This was the action of Americans in the treatment of their prisoners.”

I’m somewhat at a loss here. I don’t like to see anyone in a bad way, not even my enemies. But, come on Senator, this doesn’t rise to the level of Auschwitz. We’re at war here. I remember the first time I heard a hundred and twenty two millimeter rocket coming my way forty years ago and realizing that someone out there meant me ill. One of the first urges I had before I pulled myself together was to relieve myself. And, I’ve worked in conditions a lot worse than a hundred degrees or in a room where the air conditioner was set so low that I had to round up a firewood detail to warm the place up. About the only thing I saw here that was remotely like torture was the rap music. I think if I had to bear that all night I’d crawl up in a fetal position too.

Now, according to his bio, Durbin is a man of the people. His resume would make even Mother Theresa green with envy. Upon reading it the only thing I could see next for the good senator from Illinois was sainthood.

But bios are one thing and the real world is another. I think that his constituents, many of whom have sons and daughters serving in harm’s way, aren’t very appreciative of his loose tongue. Barring impeachment, which is very, very unlikely, though, they (and consequently the rest of us) are stuck with this lunatic till 2008.

But, after reading a post from “Feeble Knees,” I find that’s not nearly as bad as the word coming from the offices of “reverend” Fred Phelps. Durbin’s malady was mild compared to this fruitcake’s. This wolf in sheep’s clothing has really gone over the edge now. He’s apparently decided to picket the funeral of Corporal Carrie French, who died serving freedom’s cause in Iraq, telling the media and anyone who would listen that the Almighty was wreaking his vengeance on the French family and the U.S.military for wrongs the government of the United States inflicted on him:

(BOISE - AP) -
“The Kansas preacher who tried to erect an anti-gay monument in a Boise city park says he's coming to Idaho this week to picket the funeral of a fallen soldier.”

“Fred Phelps of the Westboro Baptist Church in Topeka, Kansas, says God killed Idaho National Guard Corporal Carrie French with an improvised explosive device. Phelps says God is retaliating against America for a bombing of his church six years ago.”

“French was a 19-year-old Caldwell High School graduate and varsity cheerleader. She was killed June 5 in Iraq's northern city of Kirkuk by an improvised explosive device.
French served as an ammunition specialist with the 116th Brigade Combat Team's 145th Support Battalion.”

“Phelps says there is no reason he is targeting French specifically. He says his church will protest any public funeral of soldiers killed in Iraq.”

“Caldwell Police Chief Bob Sobba said he can't bar Phelps from going to the public funeral. It's scheduled for Wednesday afternoon at the Albertson College of Idaho.”

Now doesn’t that put the lid on the jar? Do these two lunatics have the same press secretary? Did they hatch this all up on a conference call? I’m only left to wonder how far Senator Durbin would have gone if he hadn’t been prevented by political niceties.

One of these knuckleheads, a politician, merely insulted the U.S, military and, by extension, their families. The other, a counterfeit man of the cloth, wished them all dead.

I’m stunned, absolutely stunned, by what I’ve read and heard. I can only conclude that these two are, in my book, lunacy’s “A” Team.

Wednesday, June 15, 2005

Catharsis

Psalm 73:1-17 (New Living Translation)

Psalm 73

A psalm of Asaph

1 “Truly God is good to Israel, to those whose hearts are pure.
2 But as for me, I came so close to the edge of the cliff! My feet were slipping, and I was almost gone.
3 For I envied the proud when I saw them prosper despite their wickedness.
4 They seem to live such a painless life; their bodies are so healthy and strong.
5 They aren't troubled like other people or plagued with problems like everyone else.
6 They wear pride like a jeweled necklace, and their clothing is woven of cruelty.
7 These fat cats have everything their hearts could ever wish for!
8 They scoff and speak only evil; in their pride they seek to crush others.
9 They boast against the very heavens, and their words strut throughout the earth.
10 And so the people are dismayed and confused, drinking in all their words.
11 “Does God realize what is going on?” they ask. “Is the Most High even aware of what is happening?”
12 Look at these arrogant people-- enjoying a life of ease while their riches multiply.
13 Was it for nothing that I kept my heart pure and kept myself from doing wrong?
14 All I get is trouble all day long; every morning brings me pain.
15 If I had really spoken this way, I would have been a traitor to your people.
16 So I tried to understand why the wicked prosper. But what a difficult task it is!
17 Then one day I went into your sanctuary, O God, and I thought about the destiny of the wicked.

I read a short piece this morning from Real Clear Politics titled “The Homecoming They Never Received.” I found the introduction, which follows, quite moving:

“One of the greatest stains on our nation's history in the last half century is the disgraceful way in which America treated its veterans returning from Vietnam. As someone born in 1969, I've never been able to get my head sufficiently wrapped around the idea that even a portion of our country could have been so callous and disrespectful to the sacrifices made by our soldiers - regardless of what those people thought about U.S. policy at the time.”

“Treating today's soldiers and veterans the same way would be unthinkable. That's a welcome change, but it's also something that should serve to deepen our shame about the way we treated our men serving in Vietnam. Imagine what it must be like for them to watch the way our soldiers are rightfully lauded for their service and sacrifice today, and to contrast that with the memories of how they were treated upon returning home from duty. Our country owes these men an apology.”

The words were Tom Bevan's “amen” of sorts to a tribute for Vietnam veterans being held in Branson, Missouri.

As one of the thousands of veterans who serve in Southeast Asia I’m very grateful for what the organizers of the tribute have done, and I’m very grateful for Tom's kind words.

But what I find amazing is that the ones who should be thanking us never have, and probably never will. The people who don’t need to apologize to us are doing what those who should will never do. It’s been that way since we went as a nation to Vietnam and it hasn’t changed in over forty years.

I’m really grateful for those who are doing what others should have. I really am. In spite of that, however, there is still a gnawing inside many of us who served in Vietnam that will probably never go away. Oh, we’ve gotten on with our lives. But it still hurts today to see those who led us down the primrose path, those who so quickly forgot us, those who had nothing but contempt for us, succeed, to find priminent places, in the world after ‘Nam.

Now I’m sure I’m going to sound bitter in doing so, but I’ve decided to pay a little tribute to those who betrayed us during those years.

First and foremost on that list is Bobby McNamara and LBJ’s super team of advisors. For those of you too young to remember, Robert McNamara was the Secretary of Defense during the Kennedy and Johnson administrations. In that role he was one of the primary architects of our strategy in Vietnam. He’s also the guy who gave us Khe Sanh and Mutual Assured Destruction, a strategy that he often described in glowing terms:

“It's not mad! (laugh) Mutual Assured Destruction is the foundation of deterrence. Today it's a derogative term, but those that denigrate it don't understand deterrence. If you want a stable nuclear world -- if that isn't an oxymoron -- , to rephrase it, to the degree one can achieve a stable nuclear world, it requires that each side be confident that it can deter the other. And that requires that there be a balance and the balance is the understanding that if either side initiates the use of nuclear weapons, the other side will respond with sufficient power to inflict unacceptable damage. Mutual Assured Destruction. So Mutual Assured Destruction is the foundation of stable deterrence in a nuclear world. It's not mad, it's logical.”

How do those guys in the Guinness ads put it? “Brilliant.” Years after his tenure Bobby's successors scorned Ronald Reagan’s idea of “Star Wars” because it would “destabilize” the nuclear situation he and the party of my youth had gotten us into. It’s hard to imagine. It seems a bit like Newspeak. Mutual Assured Destruction was the best alternative Bobby Mac could come up with to stabilize a world on the brink of disaster. Brilliant!

You know, McNamara’s failed strategies wouldn’t bother me at all if it weren’t for the arrogant attitude he has taken since the 60’s. After thousands died in his wake, he found his way to the chairmanship of the World Bank. “Brilliant!” Then, later, in another absolute stroke of brilliance he wrote a “tell all book”, repenting for his strategic sins. He then went on the rubber chicken circuit making millions doing his grand “mea culpa.” How noble! How “brilliant!”

In the end it probably made him feel a whole better, and a whole lot richer as well. What’s really galling is that he couldn’t take full responsibility for what he’d done. He blamed the lion’s share of what happened on public opinion:

“A nation's deepest strength lies not in its military strength, military force. It lies in the unity of its people. We didn't have it. And I would suggest we probably didn't deserve it given the way we handled it.”

Can you believe those words? We lost because “we probably didn’t deserve it.” We didn’t lose because of his failed policies. We didn’t lose because of the failed strategy of stalemate he engineered. It was our fault. If that isn’t a slap in the face, I don’t know what is.

There are some who saw right through him. Even in praising his book, Ernest May had this to say about this quintessential American hero’s work:

“Land-locked country of three million hamlets, populated by people devoted primarily to singing songs, making love and raising opium. And there's a theology around it, a set of beliefs which are not recaptured in the book. And it's a little bit like--if you'll forgive my saying so--it's a little bit like a crusader's memoir written by someone who can't remember why he particularly cared about the fate of Jerusalem.”

Then, what would Oriental peasants mean to this brilliant geo-politician, the architect of the grand Vietnam strategy? Not much at all.

In the same panel discussion, Hue-Tam Ho Tai, while agreeing that McNamara had written a “valuable” book, also noted that, “As I said, the Vietnamese peasantry seems to have ranked very, very low in the decision making process. When pacification finally came in, the war to win the hearts and the minds of the people, it was fought half-heartedly.” In layman’s terms, Bobby forgot all about the people of Vietnam in his grand strategy sessions.

Well, thanks, Bobby Mac! What can we who served during your tenure at the Department of Defense say in response to your “noble” work? The only words that come to mind are something like the words of ancient gladiators. “We who served loyally, only to be betrayed by you, salute you.” “We who were denied victory salute you.” “We who died for nothing salute you!”

Next on the list is Jimmy Carter. While he never presided over Vietnam, he did find it in his heart to pardon all those who never registered for the draft or evaded it by going to Canada or move favorable “climes.” You know, those of us who served didn’t mind that act of forgiveness. But like those who led us into Vietnam, he never said a word of thanks to us. I suppose he might have if we had been willing to crawl across cut glass for him.

Another representative of the party of my youth and another slap in the face. And to think now that I actually voted for him twice. My loyalty, and the loyalty of thousands of others who served in Vietnam, was repaid by betraying us to the betrayers of our generation.

Thanks, Mr. President!

Finally, there are the policy makers to thank, the Congress and Senate of the United States. They helped get us there and then shot us right through the grease once we were there. When we needed support they delivered sanctimonious lectures. When funds were needed they made sure that the appropriations dried up. But then what did the lives of thousands of GI’s and over twenty million South Vietnamese mean when compared to the power of appropriating billions for more “worthwhile” projects elsewhere?

Of course, they could look at it all dispassionately. Few, if any of them, had sons or daughters in harm’s way. I can only speak for myself and I can say with absolute certainty that I never met the son or daughter of a congressman or senator during my year there. I guess decision making on a grand scale is a lot easier when there’s nothing personal at stake in the outcome.

Thanks, elected leaders!

So, in the final analysis, for me, I feel grateful that there are millions who appreciated the fact that we served loyally, and ably in Vietnam. Speaking for myself I can only say that I served. I didn’t do anything heroic. I just did my job to the best of my ability. I did nothing special, nothing that would merit a soap box But I have to say in all honesty that I have nothing but contempt for those who failed us when we needed them most.

Now, if I feel the way I do about those who betrayed us, I can only imagine how those who gave limbs and eyes to the cause must feel. And I can only imagine how those who came home with a free flag would have felt if they had lived through the experience. And how have they responded to us since those days? They’ve ignored us as if we didn’t really exist. And I’m sure they’ll continue to ignore us. What can I say? “Thanks!”

I guess I’ve done enough cathartic work for a day. I know that I can’t change the past, nor can I change the attitudes of the powerful. But at least I can express my outrage. I have and now I’m done.

Tuesday, June 14, 2005

Reruns 'R Us

I’ve got work on my mind these days. I now consider myself a contractor of sorts, albeit a retired contractor. Nancy and I are still working our way through this old prairie Victorian. It’s been a work in process for six years now. I keep thinking we’re getting close to the end of the trail and something else crops up. Ah, that’s the beauty of a hundred and three year old house.

With labor in mind and much to do today (we’re repainting our dining room ceiling and walls) I am going to once more resort to reruns.

I wrote the following essay around Labor Day last year. Some things have changed since then, some haven’t. We’ve added a wrap around back porch to our house, reworked an upstairs bedroom, stripped old varnish from miles of oak woodwork, and so forth. My son Michael is still in the insurance business, doing quite well. But there is a significant change there too. He’s now branching out into real estate. I’m really amazed. If someone would have told me ten years ago that Michael, my Michael, would be the first of my kids to work his way into millions I would have laughed myself silly. Michael was my carefree kid; the one who I thought was just going to float his way through life. I was, happily I can now say, very wrong.

Capitalism worked then and it works now. I see it in my son. And just ask Michael Jackson. He was able to buy justice in the same way I can buy myself a couple of gallons of paint down at Sherwin Williams or my son can buy tickets to a Chiefs game.. I’m not complaining, mind you. I wouldn’t be Michael Jackson for all the tea in China today. Capitalism is one of those forces that has allowed me to not only buy the paint, but also keep me sane. It gives my son a pretty good seat at a pro football game. No sir, I wouldn’t be Mssr. Jackson today. He’s purchased justice, but just look at him. My Lord in heaven, he’s pathetic. I actually feel a bit sorry for him. There are some things money can’t buy.

All the while these things have been going on Patrick Kelley down at the Gazette has been consistently annoying. As I said, some things change and some don’t, as you will see from what I wrote last September.

The original essay follows.

Buddy Biancalana, Karl Marx, and Patrick Kelley - A Question of Fairness

It’s Labor Day weekend. Here in Emporia, Kansas, things are quiet as they always seem to be. The weather is cool for this time of the year, by Kansas standards. I took my morning walk, passed by Terry Bassler’s house, looked at the yellow ribbon on the tree in front of his house, and said a little prayer as I passed. I got home and mowed the lawn while my wife, Nancy, weeded her gardens. At about one thirty we took a jaunt up to Jay’s, Emporia’s best hamburger “joint” to celebrate. This evening the smell of barbeque is in the air.
In short, the Labor Day holiday here in Emporia is small town America as it should be at this time of the year.
It’s not that we Emporians don’t care about what’s going on in the world. The yellow ribbon on the tree in front of Terry’s house reminds me that he is going to be deployed to the Persian Gulf in a few weeks. And just about everyone in Emporia will be going to church tomorrow to pray for the safety of men like Terry, for blessings on working men in women all around this country, and for God’s healing hand to be with Bill Clinton next week.
Over all, people here in this part of the country seem to be pretty happy. At least I haven’t seen any gangs of revolutionaries roaming around. I take that to be a very encouraging sign.
But we do have a gadfly or two here. Emporia’s “lord of the flies” is a fella’ named Patrick Kelley, editorial page editor at our local rag, the Emporia Gazette. In the five years I’ve been here I think I’ve only agreed with him two or three times. While I’m sure he’d claim that I’m the problem, I know, my wife knows, and our six cats know that I’m not.
Today was no exception. It all started innocently enough. In his salute to labor he began by saying:
"Of course, not everybody gets Labor Day off, because there is some important work that must be done every day. Give a thought to the police officers, firefighters, nurses, doctors and others who are working to keep their neighbors healthy and safe. And don’t forget the soldiers in Iraq, Afghanistan and Bosnia, who never get much of a holiday at all.”
Who wouldn’t agree with that sentiment? I found myself in complete agreement with him. I’m deeply appreciative for what all these, and other workers, do for me. I’m retired now and I know what it’s like to work. In my working life I’ve done some of the hard things. I shoveled snow door to door as a kid for a buck a sidewalk. When I was in high school I delivered groceries from the back of “Sahady’s” vegetable truck. I’ve worked as an usher in a downtown Boston theatre for forty five cents an hour. . I’ve been in the military. When I signed up I agreed to a seventy eight dollar a month salary. I’ve assembled dishwashers and refrigerators for Westinghouse for two ninety two an hour. I’ve dispatched the big rigs and have been a regional line haul manager in the trucking industry. I’ve loaded freight on freight docks. I’ve cleaned bathrooms. I started at FedEx as a customer service agent and moved on to the corporation’s logistics division and then finished my career in engineering.
Now I’m not outlining my resume to boast. I don’t think my work history is more unusual than most people’s. And, while I didn’t set the world on fire, I certainly didn’t fail. What my resume says is that I know what it’s like to work and appreciate those who do.
Well, Patrick Kelley couldn’t leave well enough alone. From his tribute to labor he launched into a diatribe against the evils of capitalism:
“A recent study by the Institute for Policy Studies and United for a Fair Economy found that the pay gap between chief executive officers and the people who work for them is widening once again. Last year, CEO’s made 282 times the salary of their average workers. This year, the ratio is up to 301.”
“At the same time, the Economic Policy Institute reports that, adjusted for inflation, American blue-collar workers wages have actually gone down since the end of the recession.
Somewhere along the way, America has lost sight of the fact that behind every success story, there are workers who make the business thrive. For every Henry Ford or Bill Gates, there are thousands more who do the work, building the cars and writing the computer code.
America’s wealth is not in its factories or its corporate cash reserves. It’s wealth is in its workers – the people with the skills and talent to make the grand ideas a reality.
Without them, the factories are just rusting metal and the entrepreneur’s grand ideas are nothing more than passing dreams.”
I read the piece and thought I’d better take a peek out my window to see if the revolution had begun. Thankfully, it hadn’t. But it’s not because our community gadfly wasn’t trying. Do his words sound familiar? If you’re not sure a couple of snippets from Karl Marx might help:
“The laborer becomes poorer the more wealth he produces, indeed, the more powerful and wide-ranging his production becomes. The laborer becomes a cheaper commodity the more commodities he creates. With the increase in value of the world of things arises in direct proportion the decrease of value of human beings. Labor does not only produce commodities, it produces itself and the laborer as a commodity, and in relation to the level at which it produces commodities.”
“Still, even today, socialism is particularly forthright in advocating direct pursuit of working class interests, even at the expense of what other ideologies consider the legitimate property rights of the wealthy classes.”
“The average price of wage labor is the minimum wage, i.e., that quantum of the means of subsistence which is absolutely requisite to keep the laborer in bare existence as a laborer. What, therefore, the wage laborer appropriates by means of his labor merely suffices to prolong and reproduce a bare existence. We by no means intend to abolish this personal appropriation of the products of labor, an appropriation that is made for the maintenance and reproduction of human life, and that leaves no surplus wherewith to command the labor of others. All that we want to do away with is the miserable character of this appropriation, under which the laborer lives merely to increase capital, and is allowed to live only in so far as the interest of the ruling class requires it.”
Of course, what Mr. Kelley failed to mention was the same study noted that workers’ wages had gone up forty eight percent over the time period while inflation had gone up forty one. He failed to mention that the 2004 study was nothing more than a rehashing of a 2001 study by the same institute that had concluded that the 1990’s was the “decade of greed.” That study also had the same buried statistics that revealed that workers’ wages had gone up thirty seven percent in the nineties compared to a thirty one percent increase in inflation. He failed to mention that the 2004 study concluded that “corporations should have to provide answers.” While they didn’t say who they should answer to you can be sure it will either be to some Congressional committee or an expert from the Institute for policy Studies and United for a Fair Economy. He fails to mention that the “Institute” has other projects. For example, one 2001 project, aimed at youth, advocated dismantling the Electoral College. The language they used was clever, designed to appeal to a young audience:
"Is the Electoral College a Fair System?
A LOT of people do not think so. The 2000 Presidential election proved the injustice of the Electoral College. How is it possible that after winning the majority of the votes from American citizens, Al Gore was still declared the loser in the presidential election?”
The institute’s “publication” list also includes interesting titles like “Power Trip – U.S. Unilateralism” and “The Pre-emptive Empire – A Guide to Bush’s Kingdom.”
Put it all together and you’ll get a good picture of what Mr. Kelley’s “Institute” is all about:
“While other think tanks celebrate the virtues of unrestrained markets and individualism, IPS is building partnerships to create a more responsible society — one built around the values of justice, nonviolence, sustainability, and decency.”
"It depends on who you ask. There is widespread agreement that the economic boom of the late 1990s decreased unemployment among low-income workers (including those moving from welfare to work) and consequently increased wages. However, many still had trouble making ends meet with hourly wages that averaged only around $7. Families still faced significant hardships in the areas of food security, inadequate child care, and insufficient access to housing (Boushey and Gundersen 2001). In sum, while many of these workers experienced wage increases that helped to pull them above the poverty line, they were not enough to allow families to make ends meet."
It’s now about 10:15 PM here in Emporia. After reading all this stuff from the “Institutes” I think it might be a good idea to look out the window once more. The barbarians may be at the gate. Someone may have resurrected Marx. I can almost hear him as I peer out my window:
I’m sure that Patrick Kelley would deny that he’s a socialist at heart. He would claim that he just wants a system that’s fair for all of us.
Well, what’s the problem then?
First, there are a lot of things in life that seem unfair. Buddy Biancalana played shortstop for the Kansas City Royals in the eighties. He hit .205 over that period. Two oh five! Do you know how much he made? About two million big ones a year! He had 113 hits and made about ten million dollars during his Kansas City playing days. That’s an average of $88,500 per hit. Now, the man couldn’t hit a baseball if he used a banjo, much less a baseball bat. I ask you, “How fair is that?”
Why isn’t this obsession with fairness fair? Because the obsession makes things worse. Economist F.A. Hayek put it this way:
“The demand for the new freedom (the freedom from want) was thus only another name for an equal distribution of wealth.”
The end of that pursuit, Hayek concluded, “Was, in fact, the High Road to Servitude.”
Why doesn’t it work? Peruvian economist Hernando DeSoto, a capitalist and advocate of free market reform in the third world, noted in his book “The Mystery of Capital” that it “is because knowledge about the poor has been monopolized by academics, journalists, and activists moved by compassion or intellectual curiosity rather than by the nuts and bolts of legal reform.”
And what are the nuts and bolts? The 2001 edition of “Geographica, the complete illustrated Atlas of the world” has some interesting statistics concerning per capital Gross National Product. The United States average was $26,980. The GNP per capita of Costa Rica, in U.S. dollars, was “$2,610. The average for Belize was $2,630. And the average for Cuba, the “workers’ paradise” was $766!
Capitalism works!
My youngest son owns a small insurance agency. He wasn’t always doing so well. I remember the bi-monthly calls I got when he was in college. “Hi, dad. You don’t suppose you could send me a bit of money, do you?” After several calls and several checks FedEx’d to Springfield, Missouri I decided the next call would produce a two (Nancy and me) on one (Michael) face to face visit. Well the call came and Nancy and I took the back roads from Memphis to Springfield. We found out that the man wasn’t working. “Why?” I asked. His answer almost floored me. “There aren’t any jobs.”“No jobs?”
“Well I guess you can get a job flippin’ burgers if you want, but who wants to flip burgers.”
“Why not? Look at this short and long term, my man. You can either do it for a couple of years while you’re going to school so that you don’t have to do it for the rest of your life or you can flip burgers for the rest of your life. Those are the options.”
“That’s not fair.”
“Get a job. My putting you on the family version of the dole isn’t fair either.”
Later that evening we stopped by a restaurant for a bite to eat. I noticed one of the busboys as I ate. He was a man about my age (about fifty six at the time). I knew nothing about him except that he had to work bussing tables. I seized the opportunity. “Do you see that guy, Michael. He’s probably a real nice guy. He probably has a family to support. He’s probably doing his best and his family’s probably doing alright too. This is just what he does. Do you know, Michael, you can do that too and I won’t love you any less than I love you now. But you listen to old Dad for a minute. If you want a better life and you want to finish college you need to start seeing the big picture.”
Well he did. He got a job and finished school. And now he’s out there working every day, just like millions of other Americans. He’s just started and I don’t think he’s making a lot of money yet, but he’s seized the opportunity and he’s going to be okay. he may hit better in his profession than Buddy Biancalana did in his, but he may not make as much money. That'll be okay too. I did better than Buddy in mine and I didn't make as much money as him either. But you know what? I'm not jealous of him; I'm happy for him. That's the way things are supposed to work.
Could things be better? Of course. But I know one thing for sure. If Patrick Kelley and the “Institutes” he so adores get a hold on the system to make it fair we’ll all wind up in the tank. Our per capita GNP will sink like an anchor. Then the revolution will really begin.

Monday, June 13, 2005

Memo to the Gazette

Proverbs 16:21-23 (King James Version)

21 “The wise in heart shall be called prudent: and the sweetness of the lips increaseth learning.
22Understanding is a wellspring of life unto him that hath it: but the instruction of fools is folly.
23The heart of the wise teacheth his mouth, and addeth learning to his lips.”

Memo to the Emporia Gazette. Would someone in the vicinity of Patrick Kelley give him a good swift kick in the ‘arse for me?

In this weekend’s edition of our local rag he chided Kansas lawmakers who are now balking at the state Supreme Court’s decision to heap on an additional one hundred and forty three million simoleons to “fix” the education “problem” in this state. As always, in his inimitable way, he gave all of us who object to the idea of throwing money at a serious problem a scathing lecture:

“Somehow, the image of House Speaker Doug Mays decked out with a musket and powder horn, leading a House rabble across 10th Street to seize the offending justices does not inspire feelings of patriotism.”

And, as almost always, he missed the real point of the raging debate. It’s this. The reason many of us object, including all of us who will not be able to vote on whether or not we should be taxed to produce the funding necessary to make this scheme work, is that the money simply will not produce the desired result.

It’s all a bit reminiscent of Bill Clinton’s 1992 electioneering. I don’t have an accurate count of how often he faced audiences of young people and promised them a “free” education. “It’s free,” he often said. “It’s free.” While those words seemed mighty comforting to America’s youth there was more than a little bit of extortion in the fine print. What was free to them was going to cost the rest of us plenty.

That’s what Patrick Kelley and the Kansas Supreme Court are now engaged in. It’s a somewhat polite, very legal form of extortion.

Now am I against education? Absolutely not! If I believed that a hundred and forty three million bucks would fix the problem I’d be glad to pay my fair share.

For the life of me I cannot understand why Kelley and the Court cannot see why the money won’t fix the problem. The only answer that I can come up with is that I’m subsidizing stupidity when I pay for my subscription to the Gazette and pay my tax bill to keep the “Supremes” gainfully employed.

Thomas Sowell said it all much better than I ever could:

“The most important thing to re-organize about education is our own thinking about it. Our purpose cannot be to project yet another Utopia as to what teaching methods are best, what education goals are the loftiest, or what kind of end-product would represent the student of our dreams. We need to begin instead by facing up to the debacle in which we find ourselves, so as to understand not only the institutional and attitudinal factors behind the failures of the educational system, but also the factors behind its successes in thwarting repeated attempts at fundamental reform. We need to face the harsh reality of the kind of people we are dealing with, the kind of bitter fight we can expect from them if we try to disturb their turf and perks – and the bleak future of our children if we don’t.”

“Despite the lofty rhetoric which is as much a part of the educational world as the cap and gown, we must face up to what educators have actually done, as distinguished from what they have said:”

“They have taken our money, betrayed our trust, failed our children, and then lied about the failures with inflated grades and pretty words.”

“They have proclaimed their dedication to freedom of ideas and the quest for truth, while turning educational institutions into bastions of dogma and the most intolerant institutions in American society.”

“All this says something, not only about educators, but also about the rest of us, who let them get away with such things. At the very least, it says something which protects misfeasance and malfeasance from detection and correction.”

Here in Kansas Patrick Kelley and the Supreme Court are sounding much like those late night preachers who grace the airwaves. I can hear them shouting now as I write - “Hundala kundala, send more money.” As I listen it seems to sound the same, but there’s a really big difference between the two groups of hucksters. I don’t have to give money to the preacher men. But as sure as I’m sitting here I’ll have to give it to the educational money pit.

I’m going to use a three pieces of anecdotal evidence now and be done with it.

The first came in the form of an e-mail from a young Moldovan woman, Corina Nour. Corina came to the United States and lived with Nancy and me almost two years ago as an exchange student. Her year here was an absolute delight for Nancy and me. She came from a country that was, and is, very poor when compared to the United States. That was as things appeared on the surface. But once we got below that surface we found in Corina a wealth of personal and national resources. In the year she attended our local high school she became one of the top students. Her English skills were better than well over half the American students attending. Her math skills were superior. Her knowledge of American government was exemplary. She was a skilled debater. Toward the end of her year here we had her take both the SAT and ACT exams. The results mirrored not so much what she had learned here, but what here entire life of learning had given her. She was in the top ten percent in math and the top fourth in English and biology.

Now I could go on, but I think you get the point. It wasn’t Moldovan money that made Corina such a success. I believe it was a combination of personal and family values and a system that, while financially much poorer than ours, made room for her excellence to shine through.

A got an e-mail from her a few days ago. She’s in the throes of taking her final exams after completing her high school education. There are several that she is required to take and each one is very, very demanding. Read the following description from Corina and compare that to what our kids in Kansas, and elsewhere in the United States, are getting:

“But besides that, I’ve gone through a really hard time, as I was constantly busy. I'm in the middle of those serious, major exams of graduating school I was once telling you about, that are called “baccalaureate” here. That’s why I had to prepare a lot and study really-really hard. You might not believe it, but I was so into studying that I didn't even realize how time went by soooo fast. I already had my Literature and Romanian language exam, which were Ok, not too difficult. The math one was really harsh, though. It was like 3 hours of torture. It was super-extra complicated, too voluminous, I didn't really manage to write everything properly, like it should be, with explanations, you know. I just solved everything, got the right answers though, but if I had like 15-20 min more I would be more content with it. Here the exams are nothing like the ones in US. You don't get any multiple choice or matching at all. You have to write everything on your own, explain, analyse, etc...And the tasks are complicated and the test covers everything you learned during all the years spent at school, so it's not on a specific topic or something. It's sooo broad. You've gotta’ know everything!”

“I'm sorry I'm telling you so much about this, you might not be interested, but it's the most important thing for me right now. I've got to graduate from school, you know, I don't wanna’ remain for another year...Well, of course I'm kidding, this won't happen for sure. I am smart enough to pass them. Plus I've prepared well.”


Can you see the two things converging? Put them together and they’re like a circle of excellence and commitment. I can assure you that this was something that money didn’t buy. Moldova simply does not have a hundred and forty three million dollars to throw at education. Knowing that, Moldovan families and their system find other ways to ensure that their young people are entering the new world of free trade and commerce. Students like Corina from Moldova see the opportunity that this new world of ideas is making available to them and they are treating it as an open door. And so is their educational system. And what is our educational system here in Kansas doing? “They’re mandating, most loudly, “Hundala kundala, send more money!”

The second example comes from, of all things, the media. Nancy and I watched 60 Minutes this evening. The second segment was about Beatrice Biira, a young woman from Uganda. She grew up in abject poverty. Her family had no money to send her to school. It seemed like her dream of getting an education was impossible. Then something miraculous happened:

“And yet, despite going hungry and not having much hope for the future, she later found herself on the campus of an exclusive American prep school. Last year, she was a student at Northfield Mt. Hermon, in northern Massachusetts.”
"How did she get there? How did she manage to pull off such an improbable journey? 60 Minutes traveled a long way to find out”
"The equator runs right across the country road that leads to Beatrice's home. You can stand in both hemispheres. Beatrice's life has become something like that in the last few years. She's had one foot in the African bush, and the other in New England -- all because of a goat.”
"It is through selling the goat's milk that I was able to [go to school],”says Beatrice, who owes her good fortune to a goat and a charity in Little Rock, Ark., called Heifer International.”
"Heifer International is known for its work distributing livestock to poor families all over the world.”
"In 1991, Heifer introduced 12 goats to 12 families in Kisinga. Beatrice’s family was lucky enough to be among them.”

“Along with the goats, Heifer sent a cameraman to Kisinga to shoot film of young Beatrice’s life. At 9, she was performing adult chores, and yearning desperately to attend school. But her family, one of the poorest in Kisinga, just couldn't afford it.”

“It seemed as though Beatrice would always be on the outside looking in. But she says she kept bugging her parents: “I was very impassioned. Want to go to school. I really wanted to go to school.(my emphasis added)”
“Enter her goat. The Heifer goats are bred to produce prodigious amounts of milk. After struggling for years just to feed her kids, Beatrice’s mother was able to sell enough goat’s milk to finally send Beatrice, then 10, to the local school.”
“From there, she won a scholarship to a high school in Kampala, Uganda’s capital. Then, she went on to prep school in New England, where it turns out, her biggest adjustment was winter.”

Did those goats cost millions and millions of dollars? No! But they were actually worth a lot more. They provided this young woman who yearned to learn with the opportunity she needed. Was the high school in Kampala she attended full of computers and all the 21st century accoutrements that American schools “must have?” Again, the answer is no. And yet Beatrice is going to succeed in life and it had little to do with lots of money. All it took was one goat!.

One more anecdote and I’ll be close to being done. I attended Judson College from 1972 to 1975. It’s a fine school. Academically, it was demanding, and in the area that matters most, there was an administration expectation that the education provided would be excellent. I wish I could say the same for some of the students who attended at the same time I did. I recall a chapel forum (chapel was required three times a week) in which microphones were placed strategically around Herrick Chapel so that students could let the faculty and administration know what they were thinking. On this particular morning a group of male students who had earlier formed a “free beer” movement got up, en masse, and strode to one of the microphones. Their spokesman, or ringleader, leaned over. “We want free beer,” he demanded. The assembly responded with laughter. I guess I should have seen it as funny myself, but somehow I couldn’t. I’d just spent eight years in the military, with my last tour having been Vietnam and had come to a place where a good education was something I really valued. I decided to respond. I went to the microphone closest to me and answered their plea. “I know how you can get your free beer.” The audience erupted in applause. The “committee” leader looked over at me from the other side of the chapel. “How?” he asked.
“Just join the VFW.”
“That’s all?”
“Well, there is a bit more to it. You’ll need to join the military, then go over to Southeast Asia and plunk your butt down in a rice paddy for a year. If you make it home without having to be shipped back in a body bag you’ll get your free beer. You can go over there and the United States can send someone back over here to Judson who really wants an education. It’ll be a fair exchange, those who want free beer for those who want an education” With those words I sat back down. The audience groaned. I’m not sure to this day whether it was because they were on my side or because they weren’t going to get their free beer.

By the way, the ringleader and his committee never took up my offer.

I think of all the money being thrown into our educational system and I think of Patrick Kelley and the Kansas Supreme Court now wanting to extort even more from the good citizens of Kansas and it makes my blood boil. So, to keep my blood pressure low and to ensure that their demands are met I have a couple of suggestions that would, if adopted, improve education in Kansas immeasurably. First, if we must keep throwing money at the problem, let’s throw it in the right direction. Send some of it to Moldova and some if it to Uganda, to young people like Corina and Beatrice who really want to get an education. Better yet, let’s set up an exchange program of sorts. We can send them our goats, so to speak, the kids who want the free beer, and they’ll send us the kids who really value an education. I suspect if the exchange is made and they come they’ll even be able to overcome the deficiencies in our current system. And, who knows, they, the students, may be able to teach the teachers, administrators, lawyers, and journalists of America something as well.

I guess I’m done. The only thing I can think of that I might be worried about missing now is being there to record it all if someone plants a size fifteen triple E brogan in Patrick Kelley’s hindmost parts. The sight of that might be something that’s really worth a hundred and forty three million!

Sunday, June 12, 2005

Sainthood - Sunday Morning Thoughts from Oswald Chambers

John 1:38-39 (New Living Translation)

38 “Jesus looked around and saw them following. "What do you want?" he asked them.
They replied, "Rabbi" (which means Teacher), "where are you staying?"
39"Come and see," he said. It was about four o'clock in the afternoon when they went with him to the place, and they stayed there the rest of the day.”

Oswald Chambers had a wonderful way of provoking his readers. I think it’s one of the signs of a prophetic temperament. Read the following from his “Devotions for Morning and Evening” and I believe you’ll see that I’m right.

While you’re at it, test your own attitudes and spiritual temperament against what he had to say.

“Getting There”

“Master, where dwellest Thou?...Come and see. Come with Me.” (John 1:39)

“Where the self-interest sleeps and the real interest awakens. “They abode with Him that day.” That is about all some of us ever do, then we wake up to actualities, self-interest arises and the abiding is passed. There is no condition of life in which we cannot abide with Jesus.”

“Thou art Simon, thou shalt be called Cephas.” God writes the new name on those places only in our lives where He has erased the pride and self-sufficiency and self-interest. Some of us have the new name in spots only, like spiritual measles. In sections we look all right. When we have our best spiritual mood on, you would think we were very high-toned saints; but don’t look at us when we are not in that mood. The disciple is one who has the new name written all over him; self-interest and pride and self-sufficiency have been completely erased.”

Pride is the deification of self, and this to-day in some of us is not of the order of the Pharisee, but of the publican. To say, “Oh, I’m no saint,” is acceptable to human pride, but it is unconscious blasphemy to God. It literally means that you defy God to make you a saint, “I am much too weal and hopeless. I am outside the reach of the atonement.” Humility before men may be unconscious blasphemy before God. Why are you not a saint? It is either that you do not want to be a saint, or that you do not believe that God can make you one. That is just what he will do! “We will come unto him, and make our abode with him.” Make no conditions, let Jesus be everything, and He will take you home with Him not only for a day, but for ever.”

Saturday, June 11, 2005

Ranchers, Rednecks, and Cowboys

I wrote the original piece on a beautiful winter day not too long ago, on a Saturday. Right now we’re a little more than a week away from summer here in Emporia. It’s also Saturday morning and it’s raining. Actually, it’s been raining for days on end now. Two and a half inches last night, a couple the day before, an inch or so the day before that, and yada yada yada. As I came downstairs this morning I was humming the first line to Bob Dylan’s “Buckets of Rain.” It just seemed appropriate.

In spite of the gloomy weather, though, this Saturday is in its own way as beautiful as that Saturday in the winter.

Nancy and I had breakfast at the Commercial Street Diner a while ago and the cast of characters was the same as it always seems to be – a gathering of ranchers, rednecks, and cowboys. With things still as hectic as they were yesterday and now compounded with a corneal ulcer that is playing havoc with my sight, I thought another rerun would be in order. The original follows:

Psalm 118:23-24 (King James Version)

“23This is the LORD's doing; it is marvellous in our eyes.
24This is the day which the LORD hath made; we will rejoice and be glad in it.”


It’s a beautiful Saturday morning here in Emporia, Kansas. Last night we had about an inch or two of snow and now the town has the look of Bedford Falls.

Nancy and I spent the early part of the morning reading the Kansas City Star and talking about the movie we saw last night. If you haven’t seen it, we highly recommend “The Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind.” The language isn’t pristine, but the theme more than makes up for the gritty language. It’s the story of a relationship, about a man and woman who want to erase each other from their memories. Through the use of technology they almost succeed, but they find that while their minds can be purged their hearts can’t. They love each other and nothing can change that. It’s well worth seeing.

I also did a bit of reading. I’m slowly plowing my way through Mark Edmundson’s “Why Read.” This morning’s little snippet was very interesting:

“To disdain TV now is bad form; it signifies that you take yourself far too seriously. TV is a tranquilizing medium, a soporific, inducing in its devotees a light narcosis. It reduces anxiety, steadies and quiets the nerves. But it also deadens. Like every narcotic, it will, consumed in certain doses, produce something like a hangover, the habitual watcher’s irritable languor that persists after the TV is off. It’s been said that the illusion of knowing and control that heroin engenders isn’t entirely unlike the TV consumer’s habitual smug-torpor, and that seems about right.”

Having read that, it only seemed right that the Weather Channel was more than enough for one day. To make sure we wouldn’t fall into a torpor we turned off the TV and decided to take a walk downtown to have some breakfast at the Commercial Street Diner.

I was ready in about three minutes and spent the next ten after than waiting for Nancy. At one point she was almost ready, but then noticed that she still had her slippers on. Another five or so for her to find her boots, the “right” hat to go with the rest of her outfit and we were on our way.

As we walked hand in hand in the snow I thought some of the odd thoughts that often drift their way through my mind. I was struck by how amazing the human hand is. It’s incredibly functional. It can grasp a monkey wrench; it can pound out words on a computer keyboard. It can show us which way to go; it can sometimes show someone where we think they ought to go. It can do amazing feats of sleight of hand; it can squeeze the trigger of a gun. But there on Ninth Street, as I walked hand in hand with Nancy, I realized that more than anything else the human hand was made for holding another human hand. Beyond any other function this amazing instrument can perform, there is nothing quite like what happens when one human hand slips into another human hand. I believe it’s because it seems to link entire beings together. It doesn’t just twist nuts and bolts. It unites hearts.

It was about 8:00 when we arrived at the diner. The place was already crowded with an assortment of ranchers, rednecks, and rowdies, Emporia’s prevailing demographic. We got ourselves seated and started looking at our menus. I don’t know why I even looked at it at all since I already knew what I wanted, a ham and cheese omelet, wheat toast, and a glass of apple juice. But I pretended to browse through it. At the top right hand corner of the menu I saw the diner’s slogan – “Home cookin’ so good you’ll think we stole your mama.”

Only in Emporia! Garrison Keillor may have his Lake Woebegone where “all the women are strong, all the men are good-looking, and all the children are above average,” but we in Emporia have our distinctive. The Commercial Street Diner is filled with ranchers, rednecks, and rowdies, our counterpart to the good citizens of Lake Woebegone. Here in the center of it all the design chic is a pair of bib overalls, a feed lot baseball cap, and a pair of Nike’s. The men here are strong, I believe custom built to brand cattle or tear an engine down. The women are pleasant to the eye, and yet sturdy enough to brand the cows along with their men (that’s about as descriptive as I care to be without getting myself into trouble with the Emporia Chamber of Commerce.). The children, well I think they’re average, maybe high C’s. But they seem good enough.

Right after the food arrived Nancy asked one of those curious questions she seems to reserve for special breakfasts like today’s. “I don’t think we Christians really rejoice in the Lord anymore, do you?” Now time has taught me that these are important moments, so I reflected for a moment to give her my best response. My response was absolutely brilliant. “Maybe yes, maybe no…..Actually I’m not sure.”
Nancy clarified. “Well I mean it just seems that we Christians spend all of our time consuming or defending the faith. We just don’t seem very happy or well adjusted these days.”
My mind wandered as she clarified. “How should the “Prairie Apologist” respond?” How could I admit that there was a lot of truth in what she was saying and save face? There was no escape. I had to voice my mea culpa. “You’re right.”
“Do you remember what it was like before we got so sophisticated? We used to sing “This is the day that the Lord has made” and mean it. Do you remember?”
“I do.”

Then the conversation changed directions. I think it was based on what Nancy took from watching the movie last night. She asked, “What would you do if you knew you were going to die at the end of the day today?"
“I don’t think I’d want to know,” I responded, “It would be more than I’d want to deal with.”

This was all reminiscent of discussions we’ve had over breakfast before, much like the one we had in New Jersey years ago. I looked around the café at the assortment of rogues in bib overalls gathered for breakfast and then looked back at Nancy. She was deep in thought. “I think it wouldn’t bother me. It would be a real signal for me to make the most of the day. Am I getting through? You know…..being able to sing “this is the day that the Lord has made” in spite of knowing it was going to be my last day here on earth.”

I didn’t respond at first. I looked around the café one more time to gather my composure. I’m not sure but I think it took a few minutes for me to respond. “I guess most of us would be franticly looking for some way to stave it off, wouldn’t we?” was about as profound a response as I could muster.

We sat tinkering with the remnants of our breakfast for a few more minutes and then noticed that Curtis McCauley had joined the crowd of rogues for breakfast. We called him over to the table and spent a few minutes getting caught up with one another. Doc, as I know him, is an interesting fellow. I first met him on a trip to a men’s retreat close to five years ago now. As we wandered the back roads of Kansas on the way to the retreat I recall the conversation he was having with Clint Longacre, a professor at Emporia State. They were kidding with one another about credentials. As they conversation progressed Clint would mention a degree he had received. Curtis would respond to each that Clint mentioned in his gravelly country brogue, “I got one of them too.” Not knowing him I suspected this might be a bit of Flint Hills hyperbole. I’ve since found that it wasn’t. Curtis looks every bit like the rest of the ranchers, rednecks, and rowdies that gather at the Commercial Street Diner in the morning, but his mind is as refined as any professor’s at any Ivy League school on the east coast.

The conversation meandered and somehow we got on the subject of stubborn people. Curtis excluded himself from “such folks” and I just rolled my eyes. “We know for sure you’re not the least bit stubborn, Doc,” I said. “It’s the other “folks” we were talking about.” Doc laughed and said that his wife Ann certainly knew he wasn’t stubborn. As we left he made me “promise” not to bring the subject up with Ann. I chuckled as I “promised” not to tell. “My lips are sealed Doc.”

Of course Ann may be reading this post in the next day or so. Ann, if you are reading this, I wanted to let you know that we all know, as you do, that your husband is not the least bit stubborn.

As we left the café I was feeling the effects of our conversations. The snow, which was beautiful before, seemed even whiter now. As we walked down Commercial Street hand in hand I noticed that the Granada Theatre had taken even more of a glow than it had as we passed it on our way to breakfast.

We turned onto Ninth Street and as we got to Congress Street we noticed Robbie Ruehlen driving toward us. We stopped and spent a few minutes talking with her. Robbie has become a good friend. We met her when we decided to find someone to clean our house once a week. I’m not sure whether or not Nancy found her through an ad or by way of referral, but however it happened it was an arrangement made in heaven.

Robbie’s been coming to our house weekly for a couple of years now. The best way to describe her work is that it’s the work of a whirling dervish. On the appointed day everything is moved to the center and the cleaning ensues. I’ve learned that the best thing to do while she’s working is to stay out of her way. That keeps me from getting Endust or Pledge or Murphy’s Oil Soap all over me.

But there’s more to Robbie’s relationship with us than that. Robbie came to us at a time when she needed some real confidence boosting. In the course of time she shared with us that she would like to go to school to study nursing but was afraid to go any further than just liking the idea. She had never graduated from high school and had somehow convinced herself that she could never succeed at something as difficult as higher education. Nancy started encouraging her to take the risk and in time she did. I think now that Robbie wasn’t sure that she would succeed, but with Nancy’s prompting and encouragement she somehow sensed that even if she didn’t make the grade she would still have a friend in Nancy to encourage her and love her.

Well Robbie succeeded beyond her wildest dreams. She got her degree, grading out at or near the top in all of her classes. I’ll bet she tackled the classroom like she does our house once a week.

She still comes to our place once a week and is also looking for a job in nursing. There’s some frustration in that search. Nursing “experience,” which Robbie doesn’t have, now seems to be the hang-up. So if there are any medical professionals out there that need a top-notch L.P.N., Nancy and I highly recommend Robbie Ruehlen.

We stood and talked there on the corner for a while and found out that Robbie’s doing better now. She’s just gotten over the virus that seems to be plaguing lots of folks around here and her energy level is back to her normal whirling dervish mode.

The brief conversation with Robbie ended and we pressed on toward home. At the corner of Ninth and Neosho a neighbor who was shoveling snow greeted us. “How you doin?”
“Not bad at all,” I responded. “My brother up in Boston’s diggin’ out from about three feet of this stuff right now.” Nancy chimed in, “And they only have one lane going into and out of their house.”
The neighbor acknowledged by saying that he had relatives up in the Boston area too. As we turned the corner on to Neosho we wished each other “good days.”

These moments we spent on the way home had a joy about them, a quiet sense of joy. I’m home now and I hope as I write what I’m feeling that you are feeling it too. This is “the day that the Lord has made.” Knowing that seems to make the snow whiter, our friends more treasured, our neighbors more neighborly, and the quiet life more meaningful. We haven’t solved any great problems; we haven’t argued any great theological questions. We’ve just lived knowing that this is “the day that the Lord has made.”

That makes us, in our quiet way this Saturday, rejoice. I hope, dear reader, that in your quiet way that you too will “know and enjoy.”