Tuesday, July 12, 2005

The Church-State Issue- Separation or Divorce?


Luke 20:21-25 (New Living Translation)

21 “They said, “Teacher, we know that you speak and teach what is right and are not influenced by what others think. You sincerely teach the ways of God. 22Now tell us--is it right to pay taxes to the Roman government or not?”
23He saw through their trickery and said, 24”Show me a Roman coin.[
a] Whose picture and title are stamped on it?”
“Caesar's,” they replied.
25”Well then,” he said, “give to Caesar what belongs to him. But everything that belongs to God must be given to God.”

Is separation of Church and State, as widely interpreted these days, really a two way street?

Many who advocate controls to prevent any religious intervention in state affairs frame the question and their answer that way. Here, for example, is what one blogger had to say about it:

“Separation of church and state is a two-way street. It isn’t just about restricting what the government can do with religion, but also what religious bodies can do with the government. Religious groups cannot dictate to or control the government. They cannot cause the government to adopt their particular doctrines as policy for everyone, they cannot cause the government to restrict other groups, etc.”

Interesting! Perhaps the author of the blog didn’t intend to use such a broad brush, but the language used certainly promotes the idea that religion should play NO role whatsoever in American political discourse.

To his credit the author does attempt to give us “religious” types some room to maneuver:

“There is, however, another public/private distinction — the one that is really at issue: private, as in what individuals do (whether in their homes or in the street) and public, as in what the government does (public funds, public housing, etc.). A free society must protect the religious expression of the former (individual citizens) but not the latter. The government has no “right to free speech.”

It’s become the most familiar argument against people of faith exercising power within the political arena. In plain language it means that as long as I express my faith, and the convictions that are born from that faith, privately I am on solid ground. It’s when people of faith attempt to influence public policy or morality that the welcome mat to religious practice is pulled out from under the adherent’s feet.

Does that sound like a two way street to you? It doesn’t to me. What it promotes, as I see it, is schizophrenia. For example, I have a real aversion to crimes like murder. Based on what’s been written above I can hold that objection privately. And, I can even hold that view in the political arena as long as my objection to such a crime stems from secular reasoning. Now that seems easy enough at first blush. After all, a prohibition against murder is almost universally acceptable. The distinction between public and private morality are compatible. No proponent of Church-State separation would argue against religious law being used as a base for secular law in such a case. Or would they? That’s the essence of what the Supreme Court has mandated for years now. That’s the essence of their most recent rulings on the Ten Commandments.

The schizophrenic nature of this type of public policy debate is especially evident when there doesn’t seem to be a public consensus on issues. The issues that come to mind in these situations are the teaching of “creationism,” “Intelligent Design,” or more critically, the issue of abortion. The courts have consistently ruled against people of faith in these types of decisions, citing the “lack” of a secular basis in what the religious were attempting to do.

It’s more than a matter of hair splitting. What it has done is effectively snuff out any chance that the religious side of the debate can possibly win. Stephen Carter, no lover of the religious right, saw this and wrote about it in “The Culture of Disbelief – How American Law and Politics Trivialize Religious Devotion.” Commenting on the 1987 Edwards v. Aguillard case ruling that Louisiana state law permitting the teaching of “creation science” alongside Darwinian evolution was unconstitutional:

“A majority of the Supreme Court missed the point in Edwards v.Aguillard (1987), with the suggestion that a law requiring schools to teach scientific creationism is unconstitutional because most of its supporters were religiously motivated – a suggestion that would also render unconstitutional the religiously motivated teaching of evolution, or for that matter, a religiously motivated nuclear arms freeze. A similar suggestion has been made by some pro-choice scholars who have argued that pro-life legislation violates the Establishment Clause because of the religious motivation of many supporters. For the religiously devout citizen, faith may be so intertwined with personality that it is impossible to tell when one is acting, or not acting, from religious motive.” (Page 111)

This all brings to mind something that happened to me in a workplace many years ago now. I was working for a farm based company, in the linehaul division. My daily job was to dispatch drivers throughout the Midwest. In that capacity I got to know each one of them very well. But one of the things I didn’t know about them early on in my experience was their religious beliefs, nor did they know mine. We just separated it all. Each morning when I’d go to work I would just shut off my “Christian” side and turn on my “secular” side. I had my job to do and the drivers had theirs. My capacity was professional, nothing more. I thought it was going quite well until one day my manager called me into his office and discussed my job performance with me. He began by asking a question – “Are you alright these days, Phil?” It struck me as a very odd place to begin a professional conversation. “I’m fine, why do you ask?”
“Well, I’m noticing something. I see the Phil who is very competent at what he does every day. He’s very professional. He makes good decisions. But there’s a Phil I’m missing.” At this point he pulled my resume out of a file folder. “Here it is. There’s a Phil who has a graduate degree in theology. Where is he these days? I ask because I don’t see him at all. You see, I hire on the whole-man concept. I don’t expect you to leave part of who you are at home when you come to work. If I felt that way I never would have hired you.”
I was stunned. I’d fallen into the trap that had been placed on societally. I wanted to be sure that I didn’t mix my faith with anything or anyone outside myself.

In retrospect I see how wise my manager was, and I also see how foolish I was.

Yet, in spite of its foolishness, the schizophrenic lifestyle I was living wasn’t unexpected. Our courts have told us that we can practice our faith as long as it doesn’t impinge on public policy. Powerful organizations have fought us tooth and nail for years now to ensure that we have no role in the public arena. And, sadly, some people of faith have fully bought the message that faith needs to be a segmented part of our lives:

“The religious community, according to Jesus, must have nothing to do with the state -- which is why the Romans with their purely civic religion hated so passionately the religion he founded. These new-fangled atheist Christians, instead of permitting their god to be worshipped along side the normal gods of all other peoples, refused to abide by the rules that governed Rome's civic religion, which was the rule of tolerance.”

What an amazing piece of exegesis! That’s not separation. That’s divorce!

The problem with this notion of separation is that it renders religion and morality meaningless, as this expression from Father John Neuhaus demonstrates:

“In recent decades, “pluralism” has become something of a buzzword. It is variously employed. Often it is used to argue that no normative ethic, even of the vaguest and most tentative sort, can be “imposed” in our public life. In practice this means that public policy decisions reflect a surrender of the normal to the abnormal, of the dominant to the deviant. Indeed it is of more than passing interest that terms such as abnormal or deviant have been largely exorcised from polite vocabulary among elites in American life.” (Page 146)

So, on both sides of the issue, from lawyers and powerful lobbyists attempting to strip religion from the public arena to fellow religious pilgrims advocating that we abandon the state altogether, faith is seen as unnecessary at best or as the enemy of the people at worst.

Doctor Carter, who I cited earlier, put his feelings about the silliness of it all this way:

“The problem does not stop with the silly fight over the rental of public school buildings by a religious group or the unhappy order to wipe the Motorist’s prayer from state road maps. We also have enthusiastic litigation – so far unsuccessful – that challenges the tax exempt status of the Roman Catholic Church because of its antiabortion policy. And why not? After all, it is a well understood rule that tax-exempt contributions cannot be used for lobbying or to support or oppose political candidates.” (Page 123)

In that light Carter saw something even more ominous:

“Perhaps, in short, it is a way of ensuring that only one vision of the meaning of reality – that of the powerful group of individuals called the state – is allowed a political role. Back in Tocqueville’s day, this was called tyranny. Nowadays, all too often, but quite mistakenly, it is called the separation of church and state.” (Page 123)

We’ve been careening down this one way street for at least two generations now. We’re well past the point of separation. What we really have now is a public arena that has divorced faith. Give it some more time and will, sadly, be banished to some sort of gulag. If/when that happens I’ll leave it to your imagination what the public square and our neighborhoods will look like.

Sunday, July 10, 2005

The Central Myth of Charles Darwin and Darwinism


Psalm 14:1 (New Living Translation)

1 “Only fools say in their hearts, “There is no God.”

A week or so ago I received a comment about Charles Darwin. The commenter claimed that Darwin embraced Christianity.

The statement was, of course, untrue. While it is true that Darwin studied theology and until he embarked on his journey of “scientific discovery” on the H.M.S Beagle, he even practiced what others called fundamentalist Christianity. But that all changed. His theory, and his subsequent philosophy of life, rejected any religion, particularly Christianity.

A few excerpts from his autobiography give vivid testimony to the real truth about Darwin’s religious thought and life. I believe his words tell us more about his belief system than many of his advocates, who try to paint a religion friendly version of Darwinism. Here, then, is the truth of Darwin’s thought, in his own words:

“By further reflecting that the clearest evidence would be requisite to make any sane man believe in the miracles by which Christianity is supported, -- that the more we know of the fixed laws of nature the more incredible do miracles become, -- that the men at that time were ignorant and credulous to a degree almost incomprehensible by us, -- that the Gospels cannot be proved to have been written simultaneous with the events, -- that they differ in many important details, far too important as it seemed to me to be admitted as the usual inaccuracies of eyewitnesses; -- by such reflections as these, which I give not as having the least noveltry or value, but as they influenced me, I gradually came to disbelieve in Christianity as a divine revelation (my emphasis added). The fact that many false religions have spread over large portions of the earth like wild-fire had some weight on me. Beautiful as is the morality of the New Testament, it can hardly be denied that its perfection depends in part on the interpretation which we now put on metaphors and allegories.”

“At the present day the most usual argument for the existence of an intelligent God is drawn from the deep inward conviction and feelings which are experienced by most persons. But it cannot be doubted that Hindoos, Mahomadans and others might argue in the same manner and with equal force in favour of the existence of one God, or of many Gods, or as with the Buddists of no God. There are also many barbarian tribes who cannot be said with any truth to believe in what we call God: they believe indeed in spirits or ghosts, and it can be explained, as Tyler and Herbert Spencer have shown, how such a belief would be likely to arise.”

Saturday, July 09, 2005

The Romantic's Ghetto


2 “and he began to teach them saying: 3“Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven. 4Blessed are those who mourn, for they will be comforted. 5Blessed are the meek, for they will inherit the earth.”
I have an on and off relationship with poetry. There are times I love working in it and times when I don’t. There those times, those rare times, when the words just seem to flow. Most often, though, I agonize over them.

I wrote the poem that follows some time ago. It’s one of those I agonized over for days. Many who read my blog assume that I’m a Midwesterner, but it’s not really the Midwest that has shaped me. I grew up the tenements and housing projects of inner city Boston. The sights and sounds of those early years of my life are always with me.

I hope that in reading this short piece you, the reader, will get a glimpse into the places I call my roots:

The Romantic's Ghetto
By
Phil Dillon

Some say their roots are in the land
In the strength and dignity of furrowed country rows
Mine are in the blaze of neon
Giving light and breath to the tenements lining ghetto streets.

Some say their faith was honed on cathedral glass
And sharpened by regal priestly robes
Mine was cut on jagged ghetto glass
And purified by the clatter of subway steel.

Some say they have an eye for distant landscapes
Or the refined beauty of a mountain stream.
Mine is tuned to a ragged ghetto face
Or the cloistered ghetto masses forgotten by the rush of time.

Where's the dignity of life to be found?
In the land? In a stream?
For some it is for sure.....Where is it then for me?
It's the romance of the Ghetto that will always fill my soul.

© 2002 Phil Dillon

Friday, July 08, 2005

The Outhouse Lawyers Revisited

“Wise men talk because they have something to say; fools because they have to say something.”

- Plato


11 “A rich man may be wise in his own eyes, but a poor man who has discernment sees through him.”

-
Proverbs 28

I think I might just re-post this gem quarterly. It contains the best advice I’ve given in my year of blogging. The original now follows, with one modification:

Every era, every generation has them. They’re society’s resident experts on everything. They know all there is to know about the weather, politics, religion, economics, law, sociology, psychology, marriage, baseball, or any other subject that folks might discuss in polite company. When I was in the Air Force we used to call these good folks “outhouse lawyers.” It was an affectionate appellation of sorts we gave these noble souls because they claimed superior knowledge on any given subject and they did so without the sweat and strain of having to learn about these particular subjects. That is, while they paraded around as experts, they actually knew nothing about what they were talking about.

What does it take to be a member in good standing of the Noble Order of Outhouse Lawyers? Not much, really. Do you have a law degree? No, but you’ve watched Judge Judy enough to know how the law works. That’s enough to qualify you. Have you ever tried to hit a ninety-five mile per hour fastball? No, but that doesn’t really stop many sportswriters who’ve never even been in a batting cage from critiquing the guys who do it day in and day out for a living.

Most often they’re harmless enough. I’ve been an outhouse lawyer a time or two in my life so I’m able to give you an example. I know absolutely nothing about repairing cars or how they actually run. I mean, nothing. Not only that, I’ve never had any real interest in knowing anything about them. But that hasn’t prevented me from acting like I sometimes do. More than once in my life I’ve stood around with the guys while the hood is up. I’ve listened to the conversations. The car won’t start or it coughs and sputters. One of they boys says, “Could be the timing.” Another pulls on a wire or two, investigating. “Plug wires,” I think. Not wanting to be left out I stick my head in and add my two cents. “Sounds to me like a carburetor problem.” Well, the moment I make my declaration everyone who’s gathered answers in unison, “Dillon, this baby’s fuel injected.”

I think you get my point.

As I said, outhouse lawyers are usually harmless enough. It’s when we start electing them or putting them in positions of power that society suffers.

Nikita Khrushchev is a prime example. In his prize winning biography, Bill Taubman notes that Khrushchev was a pipe-fitter by trade, and by all accounts a very good one. Then he joined the communist party. Now the communist party had little need for pipe-fitters, but it did have an enormous need for beaurocrats. Nikita learned this early on in his career and rose through the ranks. In the twenties Stalin appointed him minister of agriculture. What did Nikita know about agriculture? Nothing, actually. He was an outhouse lawyer. And his problem was that he was working for a man, Josef Stalin, who was also an outhouse lawyer. Uncle Joe had devised five and ten year plans to revive the Soviet economy. The plans had nothing to do with reality, but that didn’t seem to matter. If a particular goal wasn’t met there were penalties, usually dispatch to a cemetery or hard labor in the gulags. Now while he was an outhouse lawyer, Nikita wasn’t a fool. He saw that he needed as many layers of insulation between him and Stalin as he could possibly devise. With self-preservation as the goal, he succeeded. Ministries were developed. There was the ministry of winter wheat, the ministry of the beet, the ministry of summer wheat, potatoes, cabbage, and so forth. Each ministry’s appointed chief was…..an outhouse lawyer. When the five or ten year plans inevitably failed, Nikita had someone to blame. “It was the fault of the head of the ministry of the beet.” The offending minister was then either shot or given a pick to take to Siberia for his failure.

That’s pretty much how communism worked. Nancy met a limo driver once who grew up in one of the eastern European soviet satellites. He once told her that people had adjusted to communism. There was an accommodation of sorts, the people would pretend that they were working and would let the beaurocrats pretend that they were in control. That’s outhouse lawyerism at its very best.

Now we’re not to be outdone in the west. We’ve got them in positions of power too. They’re usually academics and usually lean to the left politically. They’re visionaries, or so they believe. And at the heart of their particular vision is the notion that they are infallible, without regard for contrary opinions, acting “ex-cathedra” from their ivory towers:

“What a vision may offer, and what the prevailing vision of our time emphatically does offer, is a special state of grace for those who believe in it. Those who accept this vision are deemed to be not merely factually correct but morally on a higher plane. Put differently, those who disagree with the prevailing vision are seen as being not merely in error, but in sin.”

- Thomas Sowell –
“The Vision of the Anointed” –

A great example is a “scholar” named Paul Erlich. Like most academic outhouse lawyers in the sixties and seventies he was concerned with the growth in human population. In his “masterwork,” The Population Bomb, he outlined the problem and the solution. He was convinced that by the turn of the century (2000) population would be totally out of control if something weren’t done to curb it. Like Chicken Little he declared that if something weren’t done hundreds of millions of people would starve to death. His solution was something only an outhouse lawyer could dream up – forced sterilization and euthanasia.

The turn of the century has come and is now almost four full years behind us. Erlich’s prophecy? It turned out to be false. Is Erlich still in vogue? Unfortunately, yes. I took a course in international relations last year at Emporia State and the professor somehow found a way to worm Erlich into the course material, touting him as a great hero of the people, a visionary. It’s amazing, isn’t it? Outhouse lawyers seem to have a way of cloning each other in academia.

But it seems now that the worm has turned. We conservatives have gotten the upper hand. We may not control the universities, but it seems we have considerable political power. It’s enough to make one feel drunk with that power. And therein lies the problem as we chart our national course forward. We are no more immune from becoming outhouse lawyers than Erlich, Khrushchev, George McGovern, JFK’s “brain trust,” or guys like me who don’t know the difference between carburetion and fuel injection.

Yet I hear the anthems of triumphalism sounding all across the American landscape these days. “Christians in power will make the difference.” “We’ll make things right.” “We’re the head and not the tail.”

Haven’t we learned? We’ve had Christian presidents before. Does anybody remember Jimmy Carter? He’s a really nice man. Now he does lean a bit too far to the left for me. But he is a nice man and I’m sure I’ll see him in heaven some day. Does anybody remember what America was like with him as president? Well it was a gawd-awful mess. He was one of our very worst presidents. Don’t you remember? There was the hostage crisis in Iran, the oil crisis, and the Russian invasion of Afghanistan. And how did Jimmy respond. His answer to the Iranians was vacillation. His answer to the Soviets was to punish American athletes by boycotting the Olympic Games. And his answer to American people during the oil crisis was that annoying lecture from the White House, the one where he donned a sweater, told us it was all our collective faults, and to turn our thermostats down to 51 degrees.

Maybe it was all because Jimmy Carter was a flaming liberal. That’s it! It was conservative Christians that we needed all along. If we get them into power, everything will be just fine. Right?

My problem with that thesis is that I’ve met a lot of dumb Christians in my day. They’re nice people, they’re part of my family, but they’re dumb. They know as much about running a country as those outhouse lawyers who mimic Judge Judy know about the law.

Yet I find it interesting that we somehow believe that we Christians can corner the market on intelligence and knowledge. It seem to me that the very thing we’ve accused those left leaning outhouse lawyers is the thing we’re about to engage in. We’re going to barge in and fix everything.

Really? I think we need to take a serious reality check before we barge any further than we have. Aren’t there enough examples from the Bible to warn us? King David was a great king in many ways, but his personal peccadilloes nearly did Israel in. And Solomon, as wise as he was, laid the foundation for his nation’s eventual demise. The prophets even warned Israel to walk humbly and circumspectly, but they didn’t listen. God then used the Assyrians and Babylonians, outhouse lawyers in their own right, to bring the nation to its senses. It took time, but it happened.

Given that, why would we think we, as Christians, have any greater capacity to rule justly or rightly? There’s something about power that’s seductive and we Christians aren’t immune. It seems to me that power and outhouse lawyers can make a toxic social potion. And, I think we need to beware before we barge.

There’s a better course. It’s to live our lives out, quietly, humbly, justly, living, as much as we can, in accord with our neighbors. It may not get us to the halls of temporal power, but it will make us people who have great influence on our communities.

So, I’ll close with these two things. First, we’re not to be society’s outhouse lawyers; we’re to be its servants. And second, whatever knowledge we do have comes from a secure base, a base that will keep us on the path of being society’s servants:

2 Peter 1

Making One's Calling and Election Sure 3”His divine power has given us everything we need for life and godliness through our knowledge of him who called us by his own glory and goodness. 4Through these he has given us his very great and precious promises, so that through them you may participate in the divine nature and escape the corruption in the world caused by evil desires. 5For this very reason, make every effort to add to your faith goodness; and to goodness, knowledge; 6and to knowledge, self-control; and to self-control, perseverance; and to perseverance, godliness; 7and to godliness, brotherly kindness; and to brotherly kindness, love. 8For if you possess these qualities in increasing measure, they will keep you from being ineffective and unproductive in your knowledge of our Lord Jesus Christ. 9But if anyone does not have them, he is nearsighted and blind, and has forgotten that he has been cleansed from his past sins.”

It’s as simple as that…..really!

Thursday, July 07, 2005

Terror by Day

“The heroic mujahedeen carried out a blessed attack in London, and now Britain is burning with fear and terror, from north to south, east to west.”

“We warned the British government repeatedly. We have carried out our promise and carried out a military attack in Britain after great efforts by the heroic mujahedeen over a long period to ensure its success.”

-
From the Secret Organization of Al Qaeda in Europe’s statement of responsibility for today’s terrorist attacks in London

The rhetoric is all too familiar. Islamic terrorists aligned with Osama bin Laden today proudly boasted their murder of innocents.

It’s a litany of terror that pre-dates September 11, 2001. It’s a litany that elevates murder and terror to a sacrament of sorts:

“The ruling to kill the Americans and their allies--civilians and military--is an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it.”

-
Osama bin Laden – From his fatwah issued on February 23, 1998

The terror network that was fathered by Osama bin Laden has made their intentions clear over and over and over. What sane humanity rejects they intend to implement with beheadings, suicide bombings, and terror.

They have made their intentions clear, and almost everyone in the civilized world understands. War has been declared on civilization and civilization must respond. The civilized world understands that this is a war with many fronts. It stretches from New York to Washington, D.C. It stretches from Madrid to London and from Nairobi to the Philippines. It’s a global war and civilization’s enemies have global aims.

The civilized response has been swift, and for the most part it’s been direct. Tony Blair condemned the attacks with these words:

“It is through terrorism that the people that have committed this terrible act express their values, and it is right at this moment that we demonstrate ours. I think we all know what they are trying to do - they are trying to use the slaughter of innocent people to cower us, to frighten us out of doing the things that we want to do, of trying to stop us going about our business as normal, as we are entitled to do, and they should not, and they must not, succeed.”

“When they try to intimidate us, we will not be intimidated. When they seek to change our country or our way of life by these methods, we will not be changed. When they try to divide our people or weaken our resolve, we will not be divided and our resolve will hold firm. We will show, by our spirit and dignity, and by our quiet but true strength that there is in the British people, that our values will long outlast theirs. The purpose of terrorism is just that, it is to terrorize people, and we will not be terrorized.”

George Bush had this to say:

“On the one hand, we got people here who are working to alleviate poverty and to help rid the world of the pandemic of AIDS and that are working on ways to have a clean environment. And on the other hand, you've got people killing innocent people,” George Bush has declared. “And the contrast couldn't be clearer between the intentions and the hearts of those of us who care deeply about human rights and human liberty, and those who kill, those who've got such evil in their heart that they will take the lives of innocent folks.”

“The war on terror goes on. I was most impressed by the resolve of all the leaders in the room. Their resolve is as strong as my resolve. And that is, we will not yield to these people, will not yield to the terrorists. We will find them. We will bring them to justice,” U.S. President has added. “And at the same time we will spread an ideology of hope and compassion that will overwhelm their ideology of hate.”

And Senator John McCain shared these thoughts on the events in London:

“Well, certainly the display of courage and stoicism of the British people this morning would indicate that as far as the British people are concerned. They think they can frighten us. They think they can scare us into some kind of acquiesence and they think they can frighten the Europeans,” he said.”

“It should remind us all what's at stake here. It's not just for America. It's everything we believe in for all people all over the world,” McCain said of Islamic fundamentalists. “They want to go back to soccer stadiums where they hang women up from the goal post because they showed their ankle. This is an enemy that we must destroy in battlefields all over the world.”

The world, for the most part, would add a loud chorus of “Amens” to what these leaders have said. The civilized world will not be intimidated. But, unfortunately, there are still some who live and breathe a different reality. Jamie Rubin, former Assistant Secretary of State under Bill Clinton, blithely reassured the networks and cable news outlets that the attack in London today had nothing to do with Iraq. He must have missed the following statement from Osama bin Laden on December 27, 2004 to the so called “insurgents” in Iraq killing the innocent with the same gusto that bin Laden’s minions did on September 11th, in Madrid, and now in London:

“Become diligent in carrying out martyrdom operations; these operations, praise be to God, have become a great source of terror for the enemy…These are the most important operations.”

-
Osama bin Laden – Praising terrorist attacks in Iraq and welcoming Musab Al Zarqawi into the bin Laden family/organization of terror

If Osama bin Laden sees Iraq as part of the war on terror, why wouldn’t the former Assistant Secretary of State? The answer, of course, is politics.

But, all things considered, that was just a minor political misstep. I suspect that in the days to come politicians will be making many more. They’ll be trying to assess blame when the terrorists have already told us they’re responsible. And I’m sure there will be many Democrats who will be linking these attacks to our “misguided” policies in Iraq. I guess that’s to be expected in today’s political climate.

But, beyond the attacks themselves, what I found most disturbing was the media’s reporting of the mood and nuance of the day. CNN’s Soledad O’Brien led the pack of media Chicken Littles. She was almost breathless as she reported. As I listened I got the sense that it was just about time for the British to hoist the white flag. She’s too young to remember, and perhaps she never studied much about World War Two, because if she had she would or could have learned something about British resolve.

In the throes of the Blitz of London from November of 1940 to February of 1941, Adolph Hitler’s Luftwaffe tried to make good on Der Fuhrer’s promise to “wring England’s neck like a chicken.” During that six month period 43,000 residents of London perished and close to 140,000 were injured. But the British people refused to surrender. Speaking to the Canadian Parliament, British Prime Minister Winston Churchill replied to Hitler when the Luftwaffe failed to bring England to its knees – “Some neck…..Some chicken.”

Today’s attacks were, without doubt, awful. But the terrorists, cowards to a man, have misstated their case. Britain is not “burning with fear and terror.” Media reports notwithstanding, the people of Britain and the people of the civilized world will prevail. The people of Britain will mourn their losses and we will mourn with them. But we will all go on! There is no doubt in the mind of civilized men who will win this war. The media and political operatives may fail to see the resolve and they may fail to see that this is a global war with many fronts. But civilized men don’t. This war will have an end and the right side, the civilized side, will certainly prevail!

Wednesday, July 06, 2005

Meanwhile, Back in Kansas


“For every one pupil who needs to be guarded from a weak excess of sensibility there are three who need to be awakened from the slumber of cold vulgarity. The task of the modern educator is not to cut down jungles but to irrigate deserts. The right defence against false sentiments is to inculcate just sentiments. By starving the sensibility of our pupils we only make them prey for the propagandist when he comes. For famished nature will be avenged and a hard heart is no infallible protection against a soft head.”

- C.S. Lewis – Commenting on the state of twentieth century education in “The Abolition of Man”

It’s back to business as usual here in Kansas. I’ve had a brief one day flirtation with blogging’s versions of yellow journalism with my piece about Al Gore. Nancy wasn’t too happy with it, not so much because she’s an Al Gore fan, but because she thought the antics displayed were beneath me. I tried the evil twin routine with her to explain my behavior, but it didn’t work. So, I’m back to being just me. I do have to admit, though, that it was fun while it lasted. The post generated more comments than I expected. I think some commenters saw the flames emanating from Al’s mouth and went no further. Clearly, I’d hit a raw, sacred nerve in some. I’ve thought about an apology of some sort for ruffling feathers, but it would be meaningless. It was done all in fun, and it was fun!

Here in Kansas the legislature is still deadlocked. The state Supreme Court’s ruling on school funding has not gone over well. It seemed last week that a compromise was reached on the dollars. The senate passed a bill that would have allocated an additional 148 million big ones to education, which was more than the court “required” in its ruling. But once the bill got to the house things stalled. Conservatives, the majority, wanted the funding bill attached to another bill which would more clearly define legislative versus judicial responsibilities. Democrats and “moderate” Republicans then joined forces to prevent a super majority from passing the funding bill and its accompanying bill outlining political responsibilities.

Over the weekend I spent a few minutes speaking with Peggy Long-Mast, one of our state representatives. While she doesn’t represent my district, I know Peggy as a member of our church here. I asked her on Sunday the question that’s on all of our minds – “Is there going to be some sort of compromise reached?” Like other legislators she told me that she hoped so, but that there were some wide gulfs to be bridged before that could happen. The big issue for her, and other conservative legislators, is the court’s involvement in funding. She, like other conservatives, supports an amendment to the Kansas constitution that would more clearly spell out the provisions of article 2, section 24, of the state constitution which states that “No money shall be drawn from the treasury except in pursuance of a specific appropriation made by law.” To Peggy this is critically important because she believes that the court has overstepped its appointed reach in this case. If the court can appropriate, by ruling, as they did in this case, then the precedent has been set for the court to continue to make these kinds of rulings in the future. Without an amendment clarifying article two the court has effectively eliminated the need for the legislature.

That’s the crux of the issue as conservative legislators see it.

I also spent about thirty five minutes speaking with Don Hill, my representative in the legislature. Don is a moderate who does not support the article two amendment. He told me that, while he was concerned with the court’s reach, he did not believe that the issue was important enough to attach to the school funding bill. I asked what the precedent the court had set might mean. “Could it mean?” I asked, “That a private citizen could sue the state over an issue of funding for a social service agency” and replied that it could. “Could it mean that the court could then mandate additional funding and express the additional amount to be allocated if the court ruled in favor of the plaintiffs?” He responded that it could. I also asked why he couldn’t allow the school funding bill to go forward along with the constitutional amendment bill. I don’t believe he answered the question. I did find out that he was concerned and hoped a compromise could be worked out. That’s as far as it went.

I’ve mentioned that to demonstrate much of what you’ve heard in national media where you live is close the same things we hear here in Emporia. It’s the conservatives, as the media portray it, who are attempting to get in the way of education. But I’ve heard from both sides now and it has become clear to me that the moderates are anything but moderate here. The conservatives are willing to fund education. The moderates say they are, but they are unwilling to do so as long as the amendment bill is coupled with it. I could almost see their unwillingness to do so if they, like Representative Hill, said they weren’t worried about the court at all. But my representative told me directly that he was and that the issue was important. Does that seem strange to you? It does to me.

This is all coming on the heels of the United States Supreme Court decision on eminent domain that I commented on about a week ago. The courts, it seems to me, are becoming more and more powerful, the legislatures are becoming weaker, and the potential for judicial abuse is becoming a real issue for me. The highest court in this land has determined that corporate property interests can trump mine and the Kansas Supreme Court has ruled in essence that it can mandate spending and specify the amounts to be spent. That gives the courts a unwanted hand on my wallet. I called those who ruled for the corporate interests in the national case pickpockets. I feel the same about the Kansas court as well.

I’m told that the devil is in the details. I believe it’s so in the case of Kansas education. When I asked how the court arrived at the amount to be appropriated both Peggy and Don told me that it stemmed from a study conducted by Augenblick and Myers in 1999 and submitted to the Kansas Board of Education as an executive summary in 2001. The second study was principally gravy, but I found a bit of meat once I was able to dig into the report. The funding proposal mandated by the court rested on one assumption in the summary – money:

“Using regression analysis allows us to see how pupil performance and per pupilspending are influenced by the proportion of pupils eligible for free and reduced pricelunches and the wealth or enrollment level of a school district. The regressionequations accounted for 73 percent of the variation in per pupil performance and 80percent of the variation in per pupil spending. Given that those levels are high but notperfect, we established confidence intervals around predicted levels of performance andspending to be sure that appropriate districts were identified as being low in performance or high in spending.”

That may not have been the intent of the study, but that’s what the plaintiff in the case (Montoy) and the court seized upon. The argument made was that some school districts in Kansas were, for one reason or another, being under funded. The plaintiff and the Kansas Supreme Court seem to have won. The rest of us will now have to dig further into our wallets. And, based on the precedent set, we may have to keep digging. I don’t know what the number of lawyers is per capita in Kansas, but I’m sure there are enough to make mischief for the rest of us for years to come. It’s not out of the realm of possibility that social welfare agencies will be suing on behalf of clients. And, who knows, maybe construction companies working on our infrastructure will find batteries of lawyers to sue on their behalf. We, the voters, may try to nix these attempts at theft at the ballot box, but then the plaintiffs and lawyers will waltz in and lift the money from us while we’re doing this political dance with them.

As I said, the schools will be getting the additional money. I have no doubt about it. But I also have no doubt that the money will not produce the results promised. The schools can present all the regression analysis they want. I’ve the pie charts and the graphs many times before. I spent a good part of my professional career doing that sort of analysis and can say with one hundred percent certainty that the scheme linking student performance to per pupil expenditure is nothing more than “garbage in-garbage out.”

So, that’s what the battle here in Kansas is all about. It’s not about conservatives refusing to educate their children. It’s about property and theft.

But, until the all the smoke clears, the media will continue to portray Kansas conservatives as uncaring, knuckle-dragging Neanderthals. Based on C.S. Lewis’s prophecy of sorts I used in my introduction, much of the public is falling for the propaganda. The media has “educated” their audiences well. Like Orwell’s 1984, right has become wrong in this issue. Up has become down. The moderates stonewall and say they are compromising. The conservatives attempt to compromise and are being castigated as stonewallers.

I’d be willing to bet that those of you reading this post who live in other parts of the country have already lost battles like this. You’ve been through it before and you’re now paying the price. We in Kansas are just now, thanks to Montoy and the Kansas Supreme Court, catching up with you.

Tuesday, July 05, 2005

The Fire and Brimstone Man

“Our democracy, our constitutional framework is really a kind of software for harnessing the creativity and political imagination for all of our people. The American democratic system was an early political version of Napster.”

- Al Gore



Believe it or not, fellow bloggers, Citizen Gore is still around, and he’s every bit as annoying today as he was when Bathus originally posted the photo you see at the beginning of this post. Yes, ladies and gentlemen, he is still breathing fire.

Some samples follow to show that he’s still in form. First, there’s this little gem from about a year ago:

“I am convinced that our founders would counsel us today that the greatest challenge facing our republic is not terrorism but how we react to terrorism, and not war, but how we manage our fears and achieve security without losing our freedom.”

It was a bit of a spin on something Citizen Gore must have heard at one of those moveon.org meetings that he’s been known to frequent. The turf is familiar enough to allow one to see that the inventor of the internet was playing the dummy to George Soros’s ventriloquist when he let go with his gem, as witness this piece of clever rhetoric from Soros’s book “The Bubble of American Supremacy:”

“In this respect, there is a parallel between the war on terror and the war on drugs. In the case of drugs, we are confronted by a public health problem, not a problem of crime. The public health problem cannot be properly addressed if we treat drug addicts as criminals. In the case of terrorists we are dealing with a crime. We need detective work, good intelligence, and cooperation from the public, not military action. In both cases, waging war is a false metaphor that can be used to justify repressive measures.”

This is about as massive as delusions can get. It’s clear to me that there is a grand malady infecting the political left. I don’t know what the medical term would be, but in layman’s terms it’s called a serious case of cranial-rectal inversion.

Only a month prior to the June, 2004 revelation, the wooden lips of Soros’s foil were bringing another startling declaration to all of America:

“There was then, there is now and there would have been regardless of what Bush did, a threat of terrorism that we would have to deal with. But instead of making it better, he has made it infinitely worse. We are less safe because of his policies. He has created more anger and righteous indignation against us as Americans than any leader of our country in the 228 years of our existence as a nation -- because of his attitude of contempt for any person, institution or nation who disagrees with him.”

“He has exposed Americans abroad and Americans in every U.S. town and city to a greater danger of attack by terrorists because of his arrogance, willfulness, and bungling at stirring up hornet's nests that pose no threat whatsoever to us. And by then insulting the religion and culture and tradition of people in other countries. And by pursuing policies that have resulted in the deaths of thousands of innocent men, women and children, all of it done in our name.”

Is this man living on the rings of Saturn? Are we to believe that Osama bin Laden is righteously indignant because we intend to get him? Are we to believe that Abu Musab al-Zarqawi is lopping of people’s heads and killing Iraqi civilians because we’ve made him righteously indignant? Well yes, actually. That’s the essence of what Citizen Gore said. Are we to believe that America is less safe now because of George Bush’s strategy of going on the offensive? Are we to believe that the Democratic Party would do better if they were allowed to hire inspector Clouseau? Well yes, actually. Are we to believe that Osama and Musab offer “no threat whatsoever to us?” Well yes, actually.

Strange, isn’t it? Succumbing to cranial-rectal inversion syndrome, as have citizens Gore and Soros, has a powerful effect on human intellect.

There’s a part of me that’s very sympathetic to Citizen Gore’s plight. I even think that there are times when he almost gets things right. In the recent furor over senate filibusters, for example, I was pretty close to being on his side. But then he had a relapse and reverted to old form:

“This fight is not about responding to a crisis. It is about the desire of the administration and the Senate leadership to stifle debate in order to get what they want when they want it. What is involved here is a power grab -- pure and simple.”

“And what makes it so dangerous for our country is their willingness to do serious damage to our American democracy in order to satisfy their lust for total one-party domination of all three branches of government. They seek nothing less than absolute power. Their grand design is an all-powerful executive using a weakened legislature to fashion a compliant judiciary in its own image. They envision a total breakdown of the separation of powers. And in its place they want to establish a system in which power is unified in the service of a narrow ideology serving a narrow set of interests.”


“Hello!” “Hello!” “Earth to citizen Gore.” “Is anybody home?” “Do I need to requisition a tractor so that I can help you pull your head out of the darkness?”

This cranial-rectal inversion thing is even catching. I found a website this afternoon dedicated to the veneration of citizen Gore. It’s called electgore2008.com. Can you believe that? I’m now wondering if the primary malady has offshoots that catch unsuspecting citizens off guard and cause them to do strange things. Doesn’t this seem to you to be something from the sado-masochistic school of politics? The only things missing are the whips and chains. But who knows, they may constitute the next iteration of cranial-rectal syndrome.

I read a bit of the stuff from the site and almost got too close. I found out, for example, that citizen Gore received a “webby,” an award described as the internet’s version of an Oscar. Well, whoopee! What can I say? “Watch out Russell Crowe!”

I was almost duped. I read something I’d never realized. Citizen Gore has a highly developed sense of humor. Does that surprise you? It did me. But his supporters, adorers to a man, seem to really believe this. There was snippet titled “Al Gore can be funny sometimes.” I don’t mind telling you that seeing that snappy title made me curious. So, I linked to the site and found this:

“Climate change is a problem that's not going to be solved by politicians - I know a little about that,” Gore says. “Politicians have an important role to play; but the underlying reality is going to have its effects on the market, regardless of public opinion and government action.”

“Spring comes two weeks earlier now in the US than it did 20 years ago,” he adds.”


Well, if that isn't the mother of all punch lines. “Spring comes two weeks earlier now in the US than it did 20 years ago.” I can hardly type. My side is splitting. After reading this bit of “stand-up” I’ll never have to watch Jay Leno again. How did Seinfeld miss him when he was searching for good comedy writers?

You know, I almost succumbed to the syndrome, but the laughter was good for me. I’m better now. Phew!

A few years ago most of America hoped that citizen Gore would just go away, and it seemed for a while that he had. But recent events have shown us we were too complacent. He’s back and he’s breathing fire with a vengeance. And, what’s worse is that he even has some support in his madness. This is dangerous stuff. I think it’s time to find a cure for the disease this poor deluded man and his followers are suffering from. To that end I offer two pieces of advice in closing. First, someone needs to contact the Centers for Disease Control and let them know that this poor soul and his disciples are suffering immensely. And, second, we need to requisition a fleet of tractors to assist the medical professionals when the surgery begins.

Monday, July 04, 2005

Prairie Vic




“A wide array of contemporary international treaties, ranging from the Universal Declaration of Human Rights of 1948 and the catechism of the Catholic Church to the 169th Covenant of the International Labor on Indigenous and Tribal People in Independent Countries of 1989, insist on property as a basic and stable human right.”

-
Hernando De Soto – “The Mystery of Capital” (page 165)

A little over a week ago I penned a few thoughts about the Supreme Court decision in the New London eminent domain case. I concluded with these words:

“One municipality, five judges, and a few corporations have picked the pockets of the good people of New London, Connecticut. The questions now remaining are “Who’s next?” and “What else is going to be lifted from us?”

A few days later I received a comment about what I had written concerning the New London case:

“Nor did they come for your house in 2005. The New London case involves a community trying to determine its future, and making a future that has jobs and hope for people. Private property rights should not stand in the way of doing the right thing for the unemployed and young, should they?”

It was, as I read it, an appeal to my faith and morality. How could I, a Christian stand in the way of “doing the right thing for the unemployed and young people?”

While I don’t think it’s a very good question, I’ve decided to take a few moments to explain why I believe that the right to property is a good and necessary right.

First and foremost, the right to property is established by Holy Writ. In fact, violating that right is condemned by two of the Ten Commandments. I’ll cite the references in contemporary language lest I be accused of using obscure, outdated language. The eighth commandment follows:

Exodus 20:15 (New Living Translation)

15 “Do not steal.”

And the text to the tenth commandment follows here:

Exodus 20:17 (New Living Translation)

17 “Do not covet your neighbor's house. Do not covet your neighbor's wife, male or female servant, ox or donkey, or anything else your neighbor owns.”

That seems pretty clear to me. How about you?

I’ve heard many who advocate Christian socialism remind the rest of us that the “Book” says that we should “have all things in common.” I believe in the idea, in principle. But I’ve found that many of those who advocate it have their own agendas. They all too often drape their own covetousness in King James language and tell the rest of that we have an obligation to give what we’ve worked for, by God’s grace, to those who haven’t worked for it at all. If they want to play a proof-text game I’ll give them one to counter theirs:

2 Thessalonians 3:9-11 (New Living Translation)

9 “It wasn't that we didn't have the right to ask you to feed us, but we wanted to give you an example to follow. 10Even while we were with you, we gave you this rule: “Whoever does not work should not eat.”
11Yet we hear that some of you are living idle lives, refusing to work and wasting time meddling in other people's business.”

To those busy bodies I say, “If you want to own something, get a job, save your money, and then buy the things you want. If you do that and you can call it your property. If you do that I assure you that I won’t covet what you work hard to call property, any more than I covet what Bill Gates or Michael Jackson own. You can dispose of your property as you wish, but don’t you dare come to me like a sheep in wolves clothing and tell me that you have the divine right to take what I’ve worked for.”

I suppose the commenter might argue that a person whose property is going to be taken by commercial (not civic) interests because of this ruling will be compensated. The commenter also might argue that altruism should be the ruling philosophy in these types of cases. That is, as “science officer Spock” once put it – “The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.”

There’s a small kernel of truth in the notion that a person would be compensated under such a circumstance. But would it be fair compensation? Ask those being displaced by the New London decision if they’ll be getting fair compensation and I think you’ll find that they don’t believe so. How much money would it take to replace the memories, the sweat equity, and the pride of ownership that came with their houses?

Ah, but there’s the issue of altruism. Wasn’t this decision, and the business activity that will flow from it, in the best interests the majority of us? The more I read the comment the more familiar it sounded to me. I went to my bookshelf and found my copy of Richard Pipes’ “Property and Freedom” and there it was:

“Ultimately, the propertyless will overthrow the propertied, and in the process abolish property altogether. Economic assets will first be nationalized and then become common good, with the result that everyone will contribute according to his abilities and receive according to his needs, which is the ultimate goal of communism.”

And what was the end game Marx and Engels had in mind when they formulated their theories:

“In communist society…society regulates the general production and thus makes it possible for me to do one thing to-day and another to-morrow, to hunt in the morning, fish in the afternoon, rear cattle in the evening, criticize after dinner, just as I have in mind, without ever becoming a hunter, fisherman, shepherd or critic.”

Oh joy! Oh rapture! And all that I need to do to enjoy this utopian life is to give up my right to property.

It sounds too good to be true, and that’s because, of course, it isn’t.

Several years ago Nancy and I visited Prague. The Velvet Revolution had taken place and the people of the Czech Republic were trying to re-establish democratic rule and the fundamental right to own property. We stayed a wonderful Inn called the Pension Vetrnik. The inn had been owned by the family of Milos O’Partney for centuries. The family had taken great pride in what they had built. But then the communists came and everything changed. Milos was obliged to make his home and inn available to “the people.” He was told that the arrangement was going to be “for the best” and that he would be compensated for his generosity. Of course, the opposite happened. Milos gave and got little or nothing in return.

One night as we ate a wonderful dinner prepared by Milos and his wife he told us about what life was really like in the utopian days of communism. It was, as he put it, pure misery. His life, and the life of his family, was constantly at the disposal of the communist party. What he had once owned was now owned by the state. He had absolutely no freedom. Nor did the people of the Czech Republic. I asked Milos how important that little inn was to him and he replied, “I’ll protect it at the point of a gun if I have to. No one is going to take what my family has built over hundreds of years and take it away from me.”

Now Nancy and I don’t own an inn, but we do own a Prairie Victorian in Emporia, Kansas. It’s pictured in my introduction to this post. We bought it in 1999 and we have all the appropriate paper to prove that we own it. We have a mortgage. We have a deed to the property. And, we have the receipts for all the work we’ve done restoring this wonderful old money pit. We have memories of all the sweat we’ve put into this place over the years. This house is ours. It’s ours because we purchased it. It’s ours because God Himself respects our right to own it. And it’s ours because, at least for now, the United States government also respects that right. Nancy and I have worked hard to restore our house, and we don’t intend to just throw away our investment in time and money to satisfy the economic interests of some corporate entity or some “young person” who needs a job at our expense.

The commenter, and others who read this post, probably think by now that I’m a heartless brute for thinking the way I do. But my guess is that there’s far more charity coming from my home than many of theirs. During our professional lives we made our way into the thirty six percent tax bracket and never once complained about the taxes we had to pay. In addition, we gave another eighteen to twenty two percent of our income annually to various charities. We did so because we believed that we had a responsibility to give in return for the blessings God had given us.

I haven’t opened my wallet to boast. I’ve done so to give you, the reader, some frame of reference. I don’t envy those with wealth, nor do I ignore the needy around me. But I never have, nor will I ever, adopt a philosophy of life that says, “What’s mine is mine and what’s yours is mine.” So, on this Fourth of July, when I’m celebrating American independence, I once again remind my critics that once my property is coveted, and possibly taken, my loss of freedom won’t be far behind. No amount of “altruism” they can muster will make me believe that their intentions are good. They just covet what they have not worked themselves to build. That’s not the altruism I subscribe to, nor is it the altruism that the Almighty subscribes to either.

Sunday, July 03, 2005

Liberty - America's Grand Experiment




“WHEN in the Course of human Events,
it becomes necessary for one People to dissolve the Political Bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the Powers of the Earth, the separate and equal Station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature's God entitle them, a decent Respect to the Opinions of Mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the Separation.”

“WE hold these Truths to be self-evident, that all Men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness -- That to secure these Rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just Powers from the Consent of the Governed”

- The United States Declaration of Independence – July 4, 1776

It seems appropriate for me on this Sunday before America’s Independence Day to focus my thoughts on religious liberty. To that end several excerpts from some of America’s founders, a great British thinker, and Pope John Paul II will follow. All quotations come from the text of Michael Novak’s “On Two Wings – Humble Faith and Common Sense at the American Founding.”

From James Madison

“The belief in a God All Powerful wise and good, is so essential to the moral order of the world and to the happiness of man, that arguments which enforce it cannot be drawn from too many sources nor adapted with too much solicitude to the different characters and capacities impressed with it.”

From Thomas Jefferson

“The promulgation of the great doctrines of religion, the being, and attributes, and providence of one Almighty God: the responsibility to him for all the actions, founded upon moral freedom and accountability; a future state of rewards and punishments; the cultivation of all the personal, social, and benevolent virtues – these can never be matters of indifference in any well-ordered community. It is, indeed, difficult to conceive how any civilized society can exist without them.”

From the preamble of the Constitution of North Carolina

“We, the people of the State of North Carolina, grateful to Almighty God, the Sovereign Ruler of Nations, for the preservation of the American Union and the existence of our civil, political, and religious liberties, and acknowledging our dependence on Him for the continuance of those blessing to us and our posterity, do, for the more certain security thereof and for the better government of this State, ordain and establish this Constitution.”

From Dr. Benjamin Rush

“The only foundation for a useful education in a republic is to be laid in religion. Without it there can be no virtue, and without virtue there can be no liberty, and liberty is the object and life of all republican governments.”

From Sir William Blackstone

“Upon these two foundations, the law of nature and the law of revelation, depend all human laws; that is to say, no human law should be suffered to contradict these.”

From John Paul II in 1998

“The Founding Fathers of the United Sates asserted their claim to freedom and independence on the basis of certain “self-evident” truths about the human person: truths which could be discerned in human nature, built into it by “nature’s God.” Thus they meant to bring into being, not just and independent territory, but a great experiment in what George Washington called “ordered liberty.”

“The American democratic experiment has been successful in many ways; millions of people around the world look to the United States as a model in their search for freedom, dignity, and prosperity. But the continuing success of American democracy depends on the degree to which each new generation, native-born and immigrant, makes its own the moral truths on which the Founding Fathers stake the future of your republic.”

“I am happy to take note of your words confirming the importance that your government attaches, in its relations with countries around the world, to the promotion of human rights and particularly to the fundamental human right of religious freedom, which is the guarantee for every other human right. Respect for religious convictions played no small part in the early development of the United States. Thus John Dickinson, chairman of the Committee for the Declaration of Independence, said in 1776: “Our liberties do not come from charters; for these are only the declarations of preexisting rights. They do not depend on parchment or seals, but come from the King of Kings and the Lord of all the earth.” Indeed it may be asked whether the American democratic experiment would have been possible, or how well it will succeed in the future, without a deeply rooted vision of divine Providence over the individual and the fate of nations.”

Today in America church bells will peal; tomorrow Americans will gather to celebrate our founding, this grand experiment in liberty. We will be commemorating an idea that not only goes back to our national birth, but also to mankind’s historical roots. Americans will celebrate this grand day knowing that in honoring liberty and those who sacrificed so that we can live as free men, we are also honoring the Great Creator of Freedom!

The grand experiment in liberty, conceived in the travail of our Revolution, has endured. It has been buffeted; it has been tested, and still it endures. It is our task now to ensure that the liberty others have sacrificed to give to us continues to sustain us and our nation in the future.

Saturday, July 02, 2005

Sherbucky's Secret




I’m still in a shameless frame of mind; it’s the Fourth of July weekend and I feel like vegging out. I wrote this piece a couple of months ago and those who read it said they like it a lot. It’s a tribute to Jim Kegin, film noir, and good humor.

Although some folks I know have speculated on what Sherbucky’s secret might be, no one has yet hit the mark. It appears that it will forever remain a mystery.

I hope you enjoy it…..again!

Proverbs 17:22 (King James Version)

22 “A merry heart doeth good like a medicine: but a broken spirit drieth the bones.”

I just got back last night from five days at a men’s retreat. In all about a hundred and sixty men attended, including nineteen or twenty from our church. I had a great time.

For me this retreat came at a time in my life when I’m not especially needy. Now it’s not that I don’t have needs, but right now my life is on a pretty even keel. I guess when I think about it my real need right now is to contribute. It’s a good place to be.

What the time meant for me was that I was able to just be myself and contribute in small ways to our group. As I said, it’s a good place to be. It also helped that the guys from our church are very accepting. I’m still a New Englander at heart, spending a good part of my time in a world of ideas and concepts. The guys at church are much more down to earth. Theirs is a world of cutting boards, cutting cows, or cutting pipes. At first glance you wouldn’t think that they’d fit into my world or that I’d fit into theirs. But, God’s grace and a bit of effort makes it so. The beauty of it all is that I think it brings balance to our lives. I once heard it put this way – “If you dismiss concepts and lofty ideals because you believe that those who live in those worlds are out touch or if you dismiss the work of the plumber because his world is beneath your dignity, then neither your pipes nor your theories will ever hold water.”

One of the immediate benefits of being around nothing but a bunch of guys is that the pressure is off. We could belch, pass gass, scratch our crotches, or wear mismatched clothes and no one really cared or even noticed. The getting together was all about being just company and companionship, not polite company. I don’t think I once heard statements like, “You’re not really gonna’ go out to dinner dressed like that, are you?” or “You can’t wear corduroy now, it’s past April 21st!” or “Did you just emit “something that smells like sulphur” near the punch bowl?” There in a collection of pot bellied men those things weren’t even on the radar screens.

The real highlight of the five days for me was rooming with Jim Kegin, our pastor emeritus. For those of you who haven’t read my blog for a good period of time, Jim had to step down from his day to day roles as pastor of our church and his district leadership role for the Foursquare churches in the Midwest. Not too long ago now he was diagnosed with Pick’s disease, which is described, in medical terms, as:

“A progressively degenerative neurological disease similar to Alzheimer's Disease for which there is no known prevention, or cure. Pick's Disease affects the frontal and temporal lobes first, with earliest symptoms showing up as changes in personality and a decline in function at home as well as work. Pick's Disease is frequently first diagnosed as stress or depression and then as Alzheimer's disease.”

Back in December when Jim and his wife, Judy, first announced what the doctors had told them, I wrote about the feelings it brought up in me and everyone else at Victory Fellowship. It all just seemed to be so unfair.

One of the things I really admire about Jim and Judy, though, is that from the day they made the announcement they wouldn’t allow us to wallow in pity. They’ve taken the lead by using a multi-pronged approach to this adversity – accepting it for what it is and seeking as much medical help as is possible, praying for healing, aiding the transition in leadership this has necessitated, compiling the wisdom they’ve gathered over the years, and moving on into this part of their journey of faith.

In the two days before the retreat actually began Jim and I were assigned to do some of the painting that needed to be done to get the campground in shape. It was a perfect assignment for two “thinkers” like us. While Ben Gray, Pastor Mike, Danny Horst and the other guys did the heavy work like tile, cabinets, and sheetrock, Jim and I plied our trade as “arteests,” adding the final touches. I dubbed the two of us “van Gogh and Gaugin.” If you ever get a chance to visit Camp Pomme de Terre and see the lower level of dormitory seven you’ll understand why. It’s impressionism at its very best!

I didn’t get much sleep on Wednesday night. Jim and Pastor Mike, my roommates, had a snoring duel going on. If I were to have to judge the competition I’d have to say that Mike won, more than likely because of a late spurt at about 4:30 am.

Come to think of it, I didn’t get much sleep Thursday night either. Mike had moved into one of the other dormitories and I’d found my earplugs, so I went to bed thinking that I was going to get eight hours or so of interrupted sleep. All went well until about four o’clock in the morning when, through the earplugs, I heard some mumbling. I turned over, thinking that the sound would dissipate. But it didn’t. For some reason I decided to take the earplugs out to see where the sound was coming from and what it was. As soon as I did I could hear Jim chuckling in his sleep. It was quite infectious and I began to chuckle a bit too. Then, at about four fifteen I heard the first of what where to be six words or statements. After laughing a bit Jim said, in low measured tones, “sherbucky.” I waited for a minute or two to see if something else would come to clarify, but it didn’t. Then, for the next fifteen minutes I pondered the meaning of that word – “sherbucky.” “Is sherbucky a concept I missed somewhere in my theology classes long ago?” “Something from Aquinas I’ve never read?” “Is sherbucky a place or a thing?” “Or is Sherbucky a person?” There in the stillness of the Camp Pomme de Terre night there were no answers.

My pondering was interrupted at about four thirty the following words from Jim, who was still sleeping quite soundly – “Got a ladle for that honey?” His question was then punctuated with a chuckle or two and the silence once again enveloped the room. By now I was wondering about not only who or what sherbucky was, but also whether or not I should be adding a comma between “that” and “honey.” It was all becoming a great mystery to me. I decided it would be best to start writing down the things I was hearing. At about five I recorded these mysterious words – “It’s in Arizona.” At five-fifteen there was this gem – Woo, wah…..Rope a dope.” At five fifteen there was a reminder of sorts – “Gotta get more exercise.” At five forty five it all ended with this masterpiece – “Coke, no joke.”

From that point, until about six thirty, I tried to piece it all together. “Sherbucky…..sherbucky…..It’s got to mean something. But what?” I thought. “And just what’s in Arizona?” “Sherbucky perhaps?” “Or honey?” The mysteries began to deepen. “Woo, wah…..Rope a dope.” “I mean, what’s up with that?”

And so it went until a stroke of inspiration hit me. I had gotten a hold of the stuff that made Dashiell Hamett and Mickey Spillane famous. I had a mystery that needed someone to solve it, someone like Sam Spade.

There, in the pre-dawn darkness I began to create “Sherbucky’s Secret,” my homage to Spillane and Hammett’s literature noir. My hero was Clyde Club, king of the detectives. I could almost see him sitting at his roll-top desk as the story began, sipping week old black coffee, barking at his secretary, the ever loyal, ever snippy, gum chewing Alice, “Hey Alice pull the Sherbucky file for me, would ya?” A while later I could hear him responding wryly to some Brooklyn tough who was trying to, as we say in the Midwest, “pull the wool over his eyes,” as he was looking for leads in the “sherbucky” case. As only Clyde could express it he sneered and asked his adversary, “Got a ladle for that honey?” I could then see our intrepid sleuth finding an important clue. ‘That’s it…..That’s it…..It’s in Arizona.”

After subduing a thug I could hear him explaining his self defense methods. With hands raised, knees bent, he cut loose with his famous calling card just before he leveled the crook – “Woo, wah…..Rope a dope.” It was all over in a flash. Then, as he stood over the fallen thug he had this advice to offer as he walked away – “Gotta’ get more exercise.” Finally, as he was in Arizona trying to piece it all together he found himself in a “gin joint.” As he leaned over the bar he ordered “Coca-Cola, straight up.” The barkeep, not believing what he’d just heard gave Clyde that look, you know, the one that says, “Say it again, Clyde.” In a deadpan that only Clyde could muster up he snorted in response, “Coke, no joke.”

But, try as I might, I could never quite piece it all together. I never could figure out who or what “sherbucky” was. I even tried “googling” it a little while ago. All I got was “Did you mean sherbuck?” and “Your search – sherbucky – did not match any documents.”

I’ll keep on working on it. There’s got to be an answer.

Well, for the rest of the retreat I had great fun at Jim’s expense. On Friday as we were painting I’d occasionally ask him, “So, who or what is sherbucky anyway?” At lunch that same day I asked what was in Arizona. And so it went. It even became infectious enough that the other guys picked it up, re-dubbing Jim from “Gaugin” to “Sherbucky.”

Jim handled all the ribbing with his customary humor and grace, much like he’s handled this period of adversity in his life. It was a wonder to behold.

As it has been since December this has been a time of transition for Jim, and he’s handled it all with great dignity. I believe that’s important for him and also important for those who have stepped into the roles he once filled.

The retreat leaders spent some time honoring Jim for his work over the years and talking about the transition that has taken place. As I listened to all the talk of change and new things, I was struck by something else in all of this. Yes, there is transition, there’s no denying that. But even in all the change there are still important things that Jim needs to contribute to the greater good. It’s his wisdom and grace under fire.

On Sunday, before we left for home, I shared with him about things I’d been sensing during our five days together. There was a small portion of Holy Writ that struck me as quite appropriate. I’ts from Joshua:

Joshua 13:1 (New International Version)

Joshua 13

Land Still to Be Taken

1 “When Joshua was old and well advanced in years, the LORD said to him, "You are very old, and there are still very large areas of land to be taken over.”

The first half of the statement seems to be an acknowledgment of sorts. “You are very old.” In the King James version the description of the aging process is put this way – “stricken in years.” I wondered what Joshua must have been thinking as he heard those words. Maybe memories of great victories raced past his mind’s eye, memories of Jericho and Ai, memories of great victories over the Amorites and the Anakites, memories of the day the sun stood still, memories of victories from the north to the south. Perhaps he was also thinking, on hearing the acknowledgement of his advancing years, that he was going to be lost in the transition, that his best days were now passed, that he was going to have wonderful memories of those days, but no real future.

I think it was at about that time that the Almighty reminded Joshua that “there are still very large areas of land to be taken over.” It’s was God’s way of saying to the great man, “Yes, Joshua, there is transition, but I still have a lot of work left for you to do. The years have advanced on you, but it’s not over for you by any stretch of the imagination.”

I shared my thoughts with Jim and told him that I sensed that the wisdom he’d compiled over the years needed to be documented and that the need was critical. “The generation ahead of you is going to need it,” I said. “There are going to be times coming up when the younger leaders will stumble and they’re going to need your wisdom to pick themselves up to keep moving on.”

There was a lot that happened in those five days, but for me nothing was more vital than those times I was able to share with Jim. I got to see God’s grace working in a very powerful way in his life. The shared laughter was indeed like medicine, the wisdom given, by way of transition, to a new generation of leaders was transformational.

You know, I doubt that I’ll ever finish the mystery of who or what “sherbucky” is. But something greater, more powerful was revealed in its place. It was the power of a merry heart and how, by God’s grace it is transforming Jim Kegin. While I can’t predict the future, I sense that his transition is going to be very active, very alive. Jim needs to press on with that work …..and so do we!

Friday, July 01, 2005

When Worldviews Collide




“Darwinist educators cannot afford to acknowledge to either their students or the public that there is a distinction between the data or testable theories of science, on the one hand, and philosophical or religious claims that are made in the name of science, on the other. All Darwinist propaganda depends on blurring that distinction so that a credulous public is taught to accept philosophical naturalism/materialism as inherent in the definition of “science.” On that premise scientific knowledge is deemed the least implausible naturalistic mechanism for creating complex life and therefore true.”

-
Philip Johnson – “The Right Questions – Truth, Meaning, and Public Debate”

I finished the first chapter of Benjamin Wiker’s “Moral Darwinism – How We Became Hedonists” this morning. Then, this afternoon I read a bit from Stephen J Gould, who was one of the foremost proponents of Darwinism until he died in 2002.

We Kansans who question the authority of Charles Darwin and his disciples are being pilloried almost endlessly these days. There are times the attacks seem pointless and quite amusing to me and there are times they seem to have some guiding rationale. It’s almost as if they were guided by some form of intelligence.

I remember a time when I didn’t believe the question of our human origin was important. But, now with the battle joined, I’m seeing that this really is a very critical battle in what has been painted as a war between rationalism (science) and fundamentalist religion (creationism).

When I finished the first chapter of Wiker’s book this morning it became even clearer to me. “Why?” I’ve wondered, “Have the Darwinists been so strident in their attacks against the Intelligent Design movement?” Riker must have asked the same question of himself, because he came up with what I believe is a very good answer:

“The greater charge of intellectual suppression I level at the moral Epicureans who are not scientists, but keepers of the culture, those who have gained cultural power through a variety of institutions from funding agencies and various media, to academia. They are protectors and promoters of materialism in science. Their desire to suppress or ridicule intelligent design arguments is purely moral in origin. Their support for materialist science is in no small part fueled by the realization that if the materialist cosmology were to crumble, the Epicurean moral world would crumble with it.” (Page 57)

The Darwinists understand what’s at stake, and they are going to do everything in their power to ensure that they maintain their grip on the culture. And, why not? They have a great deal to lose.

The rhetoric has been heating up for some time, and now it’s about white hot. I’ll follow with a couple of examples, one from a fellow Kansan named Jason Miller and one from the now deceased Stephen J. Gould to illustrate. First, there is this from my fellow Kansan

“Yes, Phineas Taylor Barnum would be green with envy. The master of the hoodwink would be in awe of the Religious Right were he alive today. Snake-charming, beguiling, conning, and flimflamming are at the heart of their repertoire, and their leaders leave Barnum looking like a bush leaguer. If the religious conversion business cycle hits a lull, there will be a glut of highly talented salespeople looking for work. This week, this Evangelical movement is flexing its muscle, and flashing its propagandistic cunning, as it soaks up the spotlight of national media attention in Topeka, Kansas.”

And then there’s this:

“Intelligent Design is a cleverly packaged form of Creationism which the Religious Right is attempting to sneak into public classrooms through a variety of means, including this farcical "hearing" in Kansas. In 1991, Phillip Johnson, a Berkeley law professor, kicked off the movement by authoring Darwin on Trial. The premise of Intelligent Design is that mere observation of the complexity of the universe provides “evidence” that there was an intelligent designer. In virtual unanimity, the scientific community rejects the credibility of Intelligent Design. Lacking the support of scientific evidence, research, or peer review, Intelligent Design only qualifies as a “theory” in the minds of those who are desperate to "prove" the existence of their version of the Christian God, and manipulate our children into believing in their version of the Christian faith.”

But it’s not just the “ordinary” man like Jason Miller who has been on the attack. The Darwinist scientists are also at it, as this from Stephen J.Gould illustrates:

“Punctuated equilibrium, catastrophic theories of mass extinction, hopeful monsters, and a variety of hypotheses about rapid rates of change in continuous sequences, not about unintelligible abrupt appearances, are part of scientific debate and bear no relationship to the nonscientific notion of abrupt appearance, despite pernicious and willful attempts by many creationists to distort such claims by misquote and halfquote to their alien purposes. Punctuated equilibrium, in particular, is a claim that evolutionary trends have a geometry that resembles a climb up a staircase rather than a slide up an inclined plane. It is, in other words, an alternate theory about the nature of intermediate stages in evolutionary trends not, as creationists have claimed, a denial of these stages. As a term, ‘creation science’ is an oxymoron, a self-contradictory and meaningless phrase, a whitewash for a specific, particular, and minority religious view in America—Biblical literalism.”

And what did Gould believe in terms of origins? Was there any room in his cosmology for God? Read this excerpt from his work and judge for yourself:

“It seems the height of antiquated hubris to claim that the universe carried on as it did for billions of years in order to form a comfortable abode for us. Chance and historical contingency give the world of life most of its glory and fascination. I sit here happy to be alive and sure that some reason must exist for ‘why me?’ Or the earth might have been totally covered with water, and an octopus might now be telling its children why the eight-legged God of all things had made such a perfect world for cephalopods. Sure we fit. We wouldn't be here if we didn't. But the world wasn't made for us and it will endure without us.”

Some cosmology! Gould was glad to be here, but he believed that it could just as easily have been an octopus explaining how the world works rather than him.

Now you’d think that the Darwinists would rely on their science as an answer, but they don’t. Their principle weapon is the “ad-hominem.” While I give him credit for being an ordinary Kansas citizen like myself, I have to admit that Jason Miller has a very refined sense of the personal attack. Here, for example, is one from the same piece I cited earlier:

“Our three “ring-masters” here in Kansas are “poster children” for the Intelligent Design movement, and its insidious purposes. Elected by the people of Kansas to represent the educational interests of our children in our secular public schools, Kathy Martin, Steve Abrams, and Connie Morris are selling our children out to advance the cause of the Religious Right. In a state where there is currently a dearth of funding for public schools, they chose to spend $10,000.00 on the “Scopes II” spectacle simply to provide a vehicle to support their denigration of Evolution, one of the most widely accepted theories in the scientific community. By choosing to help employ The Wedge Strategy to transform public school classrooms into religious pulpits, they are complicit in violating the First Amendment of the US Constitution and in trampling the rights of America’s 75 million non-Christians.”

Do you get the point? The Intelligent Design movement is at the heart of a plot hatched by “the religious right” to take over America and “trample” on the rights of everyone else in doing so.

Now that’s about as accomplished as ad-hominems can get!

I’d really like to hear a debate between the Darwinist and Intelligent Design camps, but I know it won’t happen until the rhetoric cools down. Even knowing that it will probably never take place, though, I have to admit that the arguments Darwinists are making these days are very persuasive. They’re persuading me that there may not be much merit to their arguments at all. If there were, I reason, they wouldn’t spend all the time and energy attacking those who question them.

Why the personal attacks? Philip Johnson put it this way:

“In this imperfect world an ad hominem argument sometimes performs the legitimate function of showing that a person has bias and hence that his or her arguments should be examined carefully. The argument is misused if it does more than that, causing us to ignore worthwhile arguments because of what we think of the person making them.”

That’s the essence of what men like Miller and Gould have done.

Not to be content with the personal attacks, the Darwinists have also been expertly using the “straw man” to great advantage:

“Many Darwinists want to pretend that the only people who doubt their theory are the most extreme religious fundamentalists. They know how to win a debate when the issue is framed as “science versus the Bible,” and so they want to keep the debate framed that way.”

As for me, I’m not a “religious fundamentalist” as described by Miller and Gould. I’m pretty well educated. I have a bachelor’s degree in linguistics and a master’s in theology. I’m sure that Miller, Gould, and other Darwinists would say that would qualify me as a “right wing fanatic.” But I, and many like me who question Darwinism, are not the men and women they’ve made us out to be. All we want is for the personal attacks to cease and the real debate to begin.

Mr. Miller argued in his piece that faith and Darwinism aren’t incompatible:

“Meanwhile, the mainstream scientific community has elected to boycott this charade. Their position is that by participating in “The Greatest Show on Earth”, they would be lending credence to the assertions that there is a controversy over Evolution, and that those who believe in Evolution are atheists by default. The truth is that the theory of Evolution has grown and changed significantly since its assertion by Charles Darwin in 1859, and scientists do disagree over some details. However, the majority of the scientific community agrees over the principal aspects of the theory. Conflict over the validity of Evolution is a sham perpetrated by the “showmen” of the Religious Right. Keith Miller, of Brown University, author of Finding Darwin's God, is a living example of one who believes in both Evolution and a Christian God. People like Miller, who are not uncommon in the scientific community or the general population, dispel the myth that Evolution demands that one embrace atheism. The scientific community is not denying the existence of God; they simply believe that proving the existence of God is beyond the scope of science, and discussion of the subject belongs in philosophy classes.”

While I don’t think it’s productive for those questioning Darwinism to assume that all its adherents are atheists by proxy, I don’t believe that Darwinists can continue to play a bait and switch game with the public and continue to get away with it. Darwinism is a religion! In 1959, zoologist Julian Huxley, remarking on the centennial of Darwin’s introduction of his theory, said this:

“In the evolutionary pattern of thought there is no longer either need or room for the supernatural. The earth was not created, it evolved. So did all the animals and plants that inhabit it, including our human selves, mind and soul as well as brain and body. So did religion.”

“Evolutionary man can no longer take refuge from his loneliness in the arms of a divinzed father figure who he has himself created, nor escape from the responsibility of making decisions by sheltering under the umbrella of Divine Authority, nor absolve himself from the hard task of meeting his present problems and planning his future by relying on the will of an omniscient, but unfortunately inscrutable Providence.”

“Finally, the evolutionary vision is enabling us to discern, however incompletely, the lineaments of the new religion that we can be sure will arise to serve the needs of the coming era.”


It’s come full circle now for me. Riker asked the right question and came up with the right answer. The debate going on in Kansas, despite the mighty protestations of the Darwinists, is critically important. And, contrary to what the Darwininsts are saying, it’s not a battle between science and the Bible. It’s a conflict of world views. The Darwinists do not want the debate to take place. There’s too much at stake for them; there's the risk that they might lose their high perch in society. But for the rest of us there’s something even more important to be determined. It’s the truth! With that as the goal, I say let the real debate begin!